SimpleMobileTools / Simple-Music-Player

A clean music player with a customizable widget, stylish interface and no ads.
https://www.simplemobiletools.com
GNU General Public License v3.0
1.28k stars 407 forks source link

Deletion should delete #401

Closed Friptick closed 2 years ago

Friptick commented 2 years ago

The delete button behavior is a bit difficult to understand.

In Tracks view, delete removes the track from the list but does not delete the file. Assuming this is intended, how would you get the track back in the list, given that the file still exists but is not visible?

Is it possible for the app to simply use the filesystem as its data model, rather than (as seems to be the case) maintaining a separate database which must always be synchronized (which I cannot see how to do)?

Thanks for advice, and for your work.

v5.11.2

tibbi commented 2 years ago

Delete always deletes the file itself, only at playlists it just removes them from the playlist. Delete and Remove are already 2 separate buttons though.

Friptick commented 2 years ago

Well in that case I believe I can report a bug, because, as I stated,

In Tracks view, delete removes the track from the list but does not delete the file

Steps to reproduce:

Conversely, in Tracks in Simple Music Player, there is the ghost of a file Track_2 which has been deleted. Long-pressing it and selecting Properties brings up the error "Track_2.mp3 doesn't exist".

In short, Simple Music Player is not showing the same thing as Simple File Manager.

What could be up?

tibbi commented 2 years ago

not sure, report it as a separate issue with steps for reproduction