search

SimpleMobileTools / Simple-SMS-Messenger

An easy and quick way of managing SMS and MMS messages without ads.
https://www.simplemobiletools.com
GNU General Public License v3.0
601 stars 217 forks source link

Sends SMS to wrong contact #640

Open dmillman opened 1 year ago

dmillman commented 1 year ago

Simple SMS Messenger 5.18.1 Simple Contacts Pro 6.22.3 Google SMS and contacts apps disabled

  1. Open Simple SMS Messenger
  2. Select an existing conversation
  3. Type a message
  4. Click send

Observed: The message appears to send normally and can be seen at the bottom in the conversation, but was sent to the wong person If you leave the conversation and return to it, the message no longer appears If you open the conversation with the person who it was actualy sent to, it does appear Confirmed with the (wrong) recipient that it was received. Every message to this number is sent to the same wrong number.

Expected: Messages should be sent to the correct people.

Background: This happened several times with an older ver, but with different users Upgraded to 5.18.1 to see if it was fixed, but can still reproduce

tibbi commented 1 year ago

can you reproduce it reliably? Doesnt the given contact have multiple phone numbers?

dmillman commented 1 year ago

I reproduced it 4 times today. It happened every time. The contact that was getting the messages is not someone I want to annoy any more than I have.

Each of the two contacts has only one single "Mobile" number.

tibbi commented 1 year ago

I dont see how would that be possible, hasnt happened to others either.. Do they at least have a similar number, name or something?

dmillman commented 1 year ago

No, the numbers are not similar. I was thinking that the I might have contacts corruption. The last time this happened, it was the same contact receiving messages, but the contact I was sending to was different.

tibbi commented 1 year ago

it will be some system issue, it never happened in other apps?

dmillman commented 1 year ago

no

lleo19 commented 1 year ago

Came here for looking an answer to the same issue that occurred to me as well.

Kitayoki commented 1 year ago

Same thing happened to me. I'm on android 11. The app version was 5.18.1.

bartlibert commented 1 year ago

I have the same issue with the latest version on a Google Pixel 7a with Android 13

vsessink commented 1 year ago

Hi, same here. Seems to happen especially with new contacts - ones that are new or non existent to the address book; and/or are new to the SMS app.

I'm trying to send an SMS to a $newcontact telephone number; now a $randomprevious number from my previous SMS's shows up.

For some reason, this $randomprevious number keeps popping up in place where I expect $newcontact. Even if I type the $newcontact number manually (i.e. I enter +316NNNNNN for SMS number). I find it utterly weird that the messed up number keeps popping up - even if I copy the new contact to a new name in the address book. up the number seems to be repeatable, i.e. once a number has been messed up, it is not possible to use their "real" number - the messed up number comes in its place.

I have seen this behaviour twice now, with different telephone numbers.

dmillman commented 1 year ago

I've stopped using Simple-SMS-Messenger because of this. Sending messages to the wrong recipient is too harsh a bug.

When this is fixed, I will go back to using Simple-SMS-Messenger.

tibbi commented 1 year ago

so is the issue always caused by the country number at the front? Or sometimes the message is sent to a seemingly random contact that has a whole different number?

dmillman commented 1 year ago

In my case:

lleo19 commented 1 year ago

well, I thought I described it quite clearly: I tried to send an MMS (due to text size, no attachment) to a contact, and message was sent to same number but different area code, both in the same country +1

tried to send it to +1 732 555-1234 and got it sent to +1 908 555-1234  The number +1 908 555-1234 was not in my contacts, it is a stranger.

so only the area code was substituted.

My own phone number area code is 908. The contact in my contacts has the right area code showing. I do not think it has country code, i.e. +1

hope this helps.

-----Original message----- From: @.> Sent: Sunday June 25th, 2023 21:29 To: SimpleMobileTools/Simple-SMS-Messenger @.> Cc: Lorant Leopold @.>; Comment @.> Subject: Re: [SimpleMobileTools/Simple-SMS-Messenger] Sends SMS to wrong contact (Issue #640)

In my case:

— Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub, or unsubscribe. You are receiving this because you commented.Message ID: @.***>

themichaelolson commented 1 year ago

I am also experiencing this issue - I send a message to a desired recipient, then back out and see the wrong recipient in the message list has received it. They respond to verify that I did indeed message the wrong person. Has happened 4-5 times today. Google Pixel Fold Android 13 (default AOSP) SMS version 5.18.2 (from F-Droid)

kiber42 commented 1 year ago

Hit me today. Responded to an SMS from a contact, it was sent to another number. Couldn't believe what I saw and sent another message, it went to the same wrong number. That number is not in my contacts; I cannot rule out that it belongs to a contact that I have deleted at some point. Both numbers have the same country code. Fairphone 4 Android 12 Carddav address book via davx5 SMS 5.18.2 via F-Droid

vsessink commented 1 year ago

DAVx5 here, too, synchronizing with an owncloud cardav service. Both SMS and address book are Simplemobiletools'.

samlemarnais commented 12 months ago

I have super frequently the same issue. I just disabled the app and switched back to Google app :'( To me, the easy way to reproduce it is to try to send a message to a number only (no corresponding contact). The app says "no contact" (OK normal) but when I start the conversation it uses a contact. Then, later, my contact reply saying "hey dude, wrong number". So I try to reply to him "shit, I don't like you, it was not for you then" but this reply is actually sent to again another contact of mine... hence, I removed the app. I tried to select the right contact to reply to but never succeeded.