Sinar / sinarngo

Sinar NGO is a set of resuable Plone components to build NGO website with integrated knowledge management and MEL features
0 stars 0 forks source link

A better definitive list for Resource Types #26

Open kaerumy opened 9 months ago

kaerumy commented 9 months ago

The current list of Resource Types https://github.com/Sinar/sinar.resource/blob/main/src/sinar/resource/vocabularies/resource_type.py is very general, missing some commonly used types and often not specific with the types of resources to be selected.

Research similar public knowledge knowledge resource categorization of large websites such World Bank, UNDP or EEA to have a better quality vocabulary that suits NGO needs.

samqi commented 9 months ago
So far this looks the closest & useful : IATI https://iatistandard.org/en/iati-standard/203/codelists/documentcategory-category/ Code Name Description
A Activity Level The document is relevant to a specific activity
B Organisation Level The document is relevant to the organisation as a whole

https://iatistandard.org/en/iati-standard/203/codelists/documentcategory/

Code Name Description Category
A01 Pre- and post-project impact appraisal   A
A02 Objectives / Purpose of activity   A
A03 Intended ultimate beneficiaries   A
A04 Conditions   A
A05 Budget   A
A06 Summary information about contract   A
A07 Review of project performance and evaluation   A
A08 Results, outcomes and outputs   A
A09 Memorandum of understanding (If agreed by all parties)   A
A10 Tender   A
A11 Contract   A
A12 Activity web page   A
B01 Annual report   B
B02 Institutional Strategy paper   B
B03 Country strategy paper   B
B04 Aid Allocation Policy   B
B05 Procurement Policy and Procedure   B
B06 Institutional Audit Report   B
B07 Country Audit Report   B
B08 Exclusions Policy   B  
B09 Institutional Evaluation Report   B
B10 Country Evaluation Report  
B11 Sector strategy  
B12 Thematic strategy   B
B13 Country-level Memorandum of Understanding   B
B14 Evaluations policy   B
B15 General Terms and Conditions   B
B16 Organisation web page   B
B17 Country/Region web page   B  
B18 Sector web page  
samqi commented 9 months ago

resource type represented in table form:

Code Name
activity Activity or Event Report
application Application or Product
updates Articles, Blogs and Updates
books Books
promotional Brochure, Promotional Materials
project_report Project or Organization Reports
data Data, Surveys, Fact Sheets
legislation Legislation, Regulations
media_article News Article
media_video News Video
media_audio Podcast or Radio
periodical Newsletter, Journal
policy Policy, Strategy or Plan
presentation Panel, Presentation
pressstatement Press Statement or News Release
research Research Reports, Working Paper
training Training Material, Guides, Organizing/Educational Materials
but added above info and comparing with sinar's resource type (added sinar closest equivalent) @kaerumy Code Name Category Sinar closest Equivalent
A01 Pre- and post-project impact appraisal Activity Level Activity or Event Report, Project or Organization Reports
A02 Objectives / Purpose of activity Activity Level Activity or Event Report, Project or Organization Reports
A03 Intended ultimate beneficiaries Activity Level
A04 Conditions Activity Level Legislation, Regulations
A05 Budget Activity Level
A06 Summary information about contract Activity Level
A07 Review of project performance and evaluation Activity Level Policy, Strategy or Plan, Activity or Event Report, Data, Surveys, Fact Sheets, Project or Organization Reports
A08 Results, outcomes and outputs Activity Level Panel, Presentation, News Article, News Video, Podcast or Radio, Brochure, Promotional Materials
A09 Memorandum of understanding (If agreed by all parties) Activity Level Press Statement or News Release
A10 Tender Activity Level
A11 Contract Activity Level
A12 Activity web page Activity Level Activity or Event Report, News Article, News Video, Articles, Blogs and Updates, Newsletter, Journal
B01 Annual report Organisation Level Project or Organization Reports
B02 Institutional Strategy paper Organisation Level Policy, Strategy or Plan
B03 Country strategy paper Organisation Level Policy, Strategy or Plan
B04 Aid Allocation Policy Organisation Level Policy, Strategy or Plan
B05 Procurement Policy and Procedure Organisation Level Policy, Strategy or Plan
B06 Institutional Audit Report Organisation Level Project or Organization Reports
B07 Country Audit Report Organisation Level Project or Organization Reports
B08 Exclusions Policy Organisation Level Policy, Strategy or Plan
B09 Institutional Evaluation Report Organisation Level Project or Organization Reports
B10 Country Evaluation Report Organisation Level Project or Organization Reports
B11 Sector strategy Organisation Level Policy, Strategy or Plan
B12 Thematic strategy Organisation Level Policy, Strategy or Plan
B13 Country-level Memorandum of Understanding Organisation Level Press Statement or News Release
B14 Evaluations policy Organisation Level Policy, Strategy or Plan
B15 General Terms and Conditions Organisation Level Legislation, Regulations
B16 Organisation web page Organisation Level Articles, Blogs and Updates
B17 Country/Region web page Organisation Level Articles, Blogs and Updates
B18 Sector web page Organisation Level Articles, Blogs and Updates
kaerumy commented 9 months ago

IATI is very donor/funder centric. eg. "Organization Web Page" and "Country/Region Web Page" "Sector Web Page" doesn't make practical sense for generic set of Resources.

samqi commented 9 months ago

actually sinar resource type is most similar to sharepoint 365 content type(PDF link).

Sourced from the 365 Support section on "Default and custom Content Types" on understanding default content type hierarchy:

Default and custom content types By default, SharePoint includes many content types. Every piece of content in SharePoint is created from a content type. You can use the pre-defined content types, such as Blank Document or Announcement, without any change, or you can create custom content types.

To understand how the built-in content types relate to each other, see SharePoint in Microsoft 365 default content type hierarchy.