search

Siphalor / spiceoffabric

Another iteration of Spice of Life
https://modrinth.com/mod/spice-of-fabric
MIT License
8 stars 18 forks source link

A logarithmic Spice of Carrot function makes no sense ... at some point there's little to no reward for eating new foods #80

Open ncottrill opened 1 year ago

ncottrill commented 1 year ago

Hi,

Log functions don't seem appropriate for adding hearts rewards for eating new foods. After a few foods, the hearts rewards diminish to nearly nothing.

This linear function works better in game and more closely follows a linear function in the original Spice of Life (Forge) Carrot Edition. health-formula: 0.6 baseHealth + max(1.001 floor(uniqueFoodsEaten), 0)

PS. This is the formula we are using in game on a dedicated server among a sizeable group of players. The fractional hearts do not cause any issue.

MissPotato commented 1 year ago

This mod seems to be balanced around other mods out of the box and not balanced against vanilla. The idea for the log based formula, I assume, is to prevent a pack with 50 different food mods allowing the player to get 1k hp or what not. However, that isn't really necessary when a hard cap already exists in the config.