search

SkepticMystic / breadcrumbs

Add typed-links to your Obsidian notes
https://publish.obsidian.md/breadcrumbs-docs
MIT License
533 stars 36 forks source link

Multiple issues related to cosmetics and hierarchy #483

Closed qazero closed 8 months ago

qazero commented 1 year ago

Describe the bug Hey, thank you for this great plugin!

I noticed 5 issues as labelled in the screenshots below. Please find the corresponding descriptions explaining each below.

  1. Is it possible to remove this for items without any parents? (not a bug, more of a question and FR)

  2. Numbering is not inline with the note titles. Perhaps it is caused by the Blue Topaz theme? Would it be possible to fix this somehow so everything displays nicely inline? (bug)

  3. For child bullets, is it possible to preserve tree like structure in the matrix view? I tried the tree view as well but for some reason I was seeing multiple duplicates, not sure why? (bug + FR)

  4. When I'm viewing the note titled 'kush' inside the Information Gathering folder, why is it listing several notes outside of this folder under 'Same'? I would like it to only list the notes within the same folder. Apologies if there is something wrong with my configuration. I tried various different configurations but couldn't get it to display right. Any ideas? (bug)

  5. I tried using the Hierarchy Note(s) option but it wouldn't update neither my matrix view nor trail view. Also, the drop down selector seems to be missing options for down as well as all others. (bug)

I'm happy to open individual issues for each of these after each is reviewed and confirmed which ones are actual bugs vs FRs. Just temporarily grouping them all in 1 report for now for a quick conversation to get some feedback.

Thanks in advance!

Screenshots image

image

image

Desktop (please complete the following information):

SkepticMystic commented 8 months ago

Hey, thanks for the issue!

I'll start by pointing out that I've rebuilt Breadcrumbs from scratch, and it's now available under V4: https://github.com/SkepticMystic/breadcrumbs/blob/master/V4.md

Saying that, I'll address the points in the context of v4

  1. I believe the default behaviour is now to display nothing if there are no parents
  2. I think this is fixed now, too
  3. The Matrix View doesn't have any depth because it only shows the immediate neighbours of the current note, it doesn't go to the neighbours of those notes
  4. I think this is a combination of a bug and a misunderstanding. Those "same" relations should be implied, not real. They are shown because those are the implied siblings of the kush note (because they share the same parent)
  5. Hierarchy notes work differently in v4 now. For one, they're called "List Notes" to disambiguate. You also declare them on a per-note level, instead of globally in the settings. You can add the BC-list-note-field: down field to a note to try it out

Let me know if that makes sense, and if you've got any questions!

SkepticMystic commented 8 months ago

I'm gonna consider this to be complete by v4. Please reopen if you run into any issues after upgrading