SnowyMouse
commented
1 year ago Message ID: @.***>Oh, hey!
This is a good idea, although I guess this goes into the "many have tried but none have succeeded" territory. Let me explain.
The truth is that the AI works fine with two players, or else Xbox Halo wouldn't work. Heck, it'll probably work with 16 players. The actual problem is, unfortunately, a bit more annoying than that.
Basically, each client has their own version of events, and this isn't being synced. The netcode of the PC version does not sync this up for AI or scripting. It only syncs it for PVP, mostly.
And before you mention MCC, one important issue to note with it is that the input lag is very high on the other player. The reason for this is because MCC does not sync events, either. Rather, it syncs timing and input and keeps everything deterministic so that both games 'happen' to show the same thing. This is also how Xbox Halo: CE does System Link and why it seems everything gets synced (not much actually gets synced).
So, the solution is to either do what MCC does and sync tick timing and try to keep everything deterministic, and then just bite the bullet and accept the input lag (on LAN it won't be too bad at least). Or, to avoid input lag, we would need a brand new netcode to sync these events (and also account for things like scripting, etc. since those need synced as well!).
Both are doable. Doing what MCC does is probably easier for a mod. But doing either would be very hard without source code access. I do think a decomp would be better suited for this.
Sledmine
Hi all
Just wondering, would it be possible to add story mode multiplayer over LAN? I think I read somewhere that the enemy AI doesn't work properly for this, simply it doesn't know what to do with two players (or more), but surely this can be fixed?
Again, just a really nice feature present in the original Xbox release, but annoyingly missing from the PC port.
Thanks to everyone who has contributed to this project!