Open Solomon0519 opened 1 week ago
The User Guide specifies that after executing the edit command, the application reverts to the full list of companies. While the status command behavior is not explicitly mentioned, it aligns with this design for consistency across commands that modify company data.
This behavior is not a bug and instead an intentional design choice to ensure users view the entire list after making a modification.
While the behavior of status could be more explicitly mentioned in the User Guide, its omission does not constitute a functionality bug. The lack of detail in the UG represents a minor documentation oversight rather than a significant feature flaw or functionality issue
VeryLow is appropriate because the behavior does not hinder the user's ability to use the application effectively. It is, at most, a minor inconvenience or a matter of user expectation mismatch. The suggestion to clarify this in the documentation could be considered for future updates but does not warrant immediate action.
Team chose [type.DocumentationBug
]
Originally [type.FunctionalityBug
]
Reason for disagreement: [replace this with your explanation]
After using the
find
command, when we try to edit the status of an application usestatus
function, the application is then reverts back to the full list of companies instead of remaining in the filtered list, this was not mentioned to happen in the User Guide, only for theedit
command.For replication purposes: 1)
clear
2)add n/Foo p/6502530000 e/google@gmail.com a/1600 Amphitheatre Parkway, Mountain View, CA 94043 cp/www.google-careers.com r/Interview process takes around 6 weeks t/difficulty_HIGH t/Shopping t/salary_MEDIUM
3)add n/Bar p/6502530000 e/google@gmail.com a/1600 Amphitheatre Parkway, Mountain View, CA 94043 cp/www.google-careers.com r/Interview process takes around 6 weeks t/difficulty_HIGH t/Shopping t/salary_MEDIUM
4)add n/Baz p/6502530000 e/google@gmail.com a/1600 Amphitheatre Parkway, Mountain View, CA 94043 cp/www.google-careers.com r/Interview process takes around 6 weeks t/difficulty_HIGH t/Shopping t/salary_MEDIUM
5)find baz
6)status 1 as/Applied
Maybe similarly for the
edit
command, could update the DG such that it also says that the application will display the full list after the commandAfter
find bar
:After
status 1 as/Applied
: