search

SovereignCloudStack / standards

SCS standards in a machine readable format
https://scs.community/
Creative Commons Attribution Share Alike 4.0 International
34 stars 23 forks source link

[Other] remove parts of image-md-check pertaining to deprecated certificate scopes? #578

Closed cah-hbaum closed 5 months ago

cah-hbaum commented 5 months ago

The image-md-check.py has the possibility to check if all mandatory, recommended and suggested images are available. This check (and list) seems unnecessary and even incorrect, since mandatory (and recommended) images are covered by the scs-0104-vX-images.yaml and the test using this file as well as the standard scs-0104-v1-standard-images.

The current version of image-md-check.py seems to be from a time, when both these standards we're combined. I would suggest cleaning this old file up to make the test conform with the standard.

mbuechse commented 5 months ago

As of now, the check script can be used to check for all versions of the certificate scope "SCS-compatible IaaS" -- even the deprecated ones. For v3 as well as the current version v4, we invoke this script with -s, so it doesn't do the completeness check.

Removing the completeness check altogether would be a breaking change, because the CLI syntax would probably change, but most of all, we could no longer test for the obsolete scope versions. We can do it if everone is on board.

mbuechse commented 5 months ago

Minor addendum: in this case, we would probably alter the corresponding check entries in the yaml file to indicate that the check cannot be performed any more (at least not to completion), and I'm not sure if this is actually legitimate...