SovereignCloudStack / standards

SCS standards in a machine readable format
https://scs.community/
Creative Commons Attribution Share Alike 4.0 International
34 stars 23 forks source link

Discontinue Domain Manager standard once OpenStack 2024.2 lands in SCS #723

Open markus-hentsch opened 2 months ago

markus-hentsch commented 2 months ago

Current State

Desired State

Once SCS incorporates OpenStack 2024.2 or later, where the Domain Manager functionality is available natively in OpenStack, the following things need to happen:

  1. The SCS Domain Manager standard needs to be deprecated. It needs to either be removed or replaced by a v2 that omits any of the SCS-specific policy configuration, as it will not be necessary anymore and conflict with the native implementation. Explanations about is_domain_managed_role and an Octavia role integration could be remaining parts of a v2 although I think it would better fit in the Role Standard. I see little reason for keeping the standard at all. Update: #586 now differentiates between pre- and post-2024.2 versions of Keystone. As such, the standard can live on for the time being. In the future, all the pre-2024.2 parts can be removed.
  2. The docs page at docs/05-iam/domain-manager-setup-and-usage.md needs to be updated and reference to the Domain Manager standard be removed or replaced in a way that omits the SCS-specific policy configurations. Only the part about adjusting the is_domain_managed_role rule should stay as this will still be valid and required for the Octavia LBaaS role integration.
  3. SCS operators need to be notified to remove the Keystone policy extensions of the Domain Manager standard when upgrading to the SCS release that incorporates OpenStack 2024.2 or later.
markus-hentsch commented 1 month ago

2. The docs page at docs/05-iam/domain-manager-setup-and-usage.md needs to be updated and reference to the Domain Manager standard be removed or replaced in a way that omits the SCS-specific policy configurations. Only the part about adjusting the is_domain_managed_role rule should stay as this will still be valid and required for the Octavia LBaaS role integration.

We might be able to greatly shrink this down and simply point to https://docs.openstack.org/keystone/latest/user/index.html depending on how https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/keystone/+/928135 goes.