SpecialProjectADU / Site

1 stars 0 forks source link

Enhancements to SignUp #41

Closed Moutasim02 closed 1 year ago

Moutasim02 commented 1 year ago

Seems too crowded, maybe try making it removing some fields, like confirm password and national id or phone number

binHarby commented 1 year ago

@rahaf2201 @Moutasim02 I'll close this if there isn't enough details or an action toward solving

Moutasim02 commented 1 year ago

image @rahaf2201 @binHarby This screen needs rework based on the same approach as logging in, The base code should be following the existing code of Login.html.

As a type of UX enhancement, users for sure won't be able to have their IDs in the first time they enter the website, and by this we are eliminating global user registration, for the confirm password, this is the trend now, it's no more required, phone number can be optional too.

Here is how Login.html looks like: image

binHarby commented 1 year ago

Okay I agree with that it does is diverges or is different from the original design, the signup design is relativly similar to the login, with two columns being in center. @Moutasim02 @rahaf2201

But on the other issue you mention, I don't agree. As far as the UAE ID, the project is meant for national level not global. We can debate this on Whatsapp, but for the sake of finishing and the coming demo with H.H office, i say we keep it.

moreover the UAE ID, it will limit initial bot accounts, limit inappropiate content posts, and provide better integrations with existing government services that would help the website become more official and government oriented .

binHarby commented 1 year ago

lets discuss the uae id more on whatsapp with the Dr and the group @Moutasim02

binHarby commented 1 year ago

@AlyafeiAli do you think 'confirm password' on signup is not required ? I still see it with some websites tbh

Also this is a design modification @Moutasim02 disagreement on this should've been stated earlier

AlyafeiAli commented 1 year ago

@AlyafeiAli do you think 'confirm password' on signup is not required ? I still see it with some websites tbh

Also this is a design modification @Moutasim02 disagreement on this should've been stated earlier

it's better to keep it as that's what the userbase are familiar with and comfortable with..
the trend nowadays is to ditch it, but I only saw this trend in few websites, and the majority are still using it..
we don't want to confuse the userbase.. they may feel that something is wrong when they don't see the second field lol

binHarby commented 1 year ago

okay, lets try be similar to the design then. This seems to be appropriate action to solve this bug @rahaf2201 @Moutasim02

Moutasim02 commented 1 year ago

I agree with whatever suggested earlier, and believe we can proceed with it without any problem, But since National ID is a requirement, we have to add it to the requirements after third-party sign-up (Google, FB, etc.) too.

binHarby commented 1 year ago

Hmm , good point. a third party login would bypass providing the UAE ID. lets revisit this when we do the actual third party login integrations

rahaf2201 commented 1 year ago

A lot of going back and forth on different decisions but I did my best on trying to fix things so here are the new Sign Up and Login Pages on how they look like:

image image

Moutasim02 commented 1 year ago

@rahaf2201 I believe Sign Up is fine, and by the way, I already fixed Log in before, and included some icons for third-party sign-in/up, I believe you can take their code and just apply it to your design, and keep the colors as of the standard colors.

https://github.com/SpecialProjectADU/Site/blob/master/docs/Standards.md

binHarby commented 1 year ago

@Moutasim02 close this or ?

binHarby commented 1 year ago

closing this