SpeciesFileGroup / taxonworks

Workbench for biodiversity informatics.
http://taxonworks.org
Other
85 stars 25 forks source link

New Taxon Name Task - Relationship Soft Validation #1781

Closed mabecabrera closed 3 years ago

mabecabrera commented 3 years ago

When exercising with homonyms we created a New Taxon Name: Jivarus viridis by Braun, 2008. This name already existed for another species, Jivarus viridis Ronderos, 1979. So,from the J. viridis Braun, 2008, we create the relationship with J. viridis Ronderos, 1979, primary homonym.

Then we create a new name for the Braun species, Jivarus elegans Pocco, 2015. From Braun`s viridis species we create the relationship with this new name, replaced by Jivarus elegans Pocco, 2015.

image

And we Edit the relationship of Poccos name with Brauns one. Nomen novum for Jivarus viridis Braun, 2008.

In the Soft Validation for this name, for Relationship appears the message: Jivarus elegans Pocco, 2015 and Jivarus viridis Braun, 2008 are not similar enough to be homonyms.

image

But as they are not homonyms we wonder what is the Taxon Works program interpretation.

mjy commented 3 years ago

If required please provide answer in taxonworks_doc.

proceps commented 3 years ago

I will check it, looks like a bug. Although, nomen novum relaitionship is not required, Replaced by relationship should resolve the names correctly.