SpikeHD / Dorion

Tiny alternative Discord client with a smaller footprint, snappier startup, themes, plugins and more!
https://spikehd.github.io/projects/dorion/
GNU General Public License v3.0
575 stars 18 forks source link

[Feature Request] Revamped logo / Custom icon support #233

Closed 27rogi closed 4 months ago

27rogi commented 4 months ago

Is your feature request related to a problem? Please describe. Request is only related to design choise for the logo.

Describe the solution you'd like I really like this application and use it as main Discord client, yet I think there's a gap between original client icon design and the one used in Dorion. I decided to design some concept logos that still feature D and o combination with D being the main point of change, I decided to give it more sleek look and sharp edges that demonstrate speed/motion, because Dorion is very speed/performance oriented.

Describe alternatives you've considered Icon can be changed personally to anything user will like via settings (custom icon support)

If needed I can provide fully separated SVG logo files, due to GitHub limitations I'm unable to upload the archive. dorion_full

SpikeHD commented 4 months ago

While I'm not opposed to an icon change (specifically middle-bottom would probably be what I prefer, but I'd have to ask other people for thoughts), all major OS support changing the icon of applications:

SpikeHD commented 4 months ago

I've asked a couple people, they agree that the middle-bottom one is the best. I'm curious how it'd look with the same "drop shadow" effect as the current icon, since I've always liked it, so if you're able to recreate it with that effect I'd love to see it as well!

You can also make a PR to change the icons by doing the following, when you're ready:

  1. Fork this repo
  2. Clone your fork
  3. Put your HQ icon.png in the root of the folder
  4. Run pnpm install (or npm install or whatever you prefer)
  5. Run pnpm tauri icon -o src-tauri/icons/ icon.png, it should generate all the required icons and replace the old ones (see the Tauri icon docs if you need more detail)
27rogi commented 4 months ago

I've asked a couple people, they agree that the middle-bottom one is the best. I'm curious how it'd look with the same "drop shadow" effect as the current icon, since I've always liked it, so if you're able to recreate it with that effect I'd love to see it as well!

You can also make a PR to change the icons by doing the following, when you're ready:

  1. Fork this repo
  2. Clone your fork
  3. Put your HQ icon.png in the root of the folder
  4. Run pnpm install (or npm install or whatever you prefer)
  5. Run pnpm tauri icon -o src-tauri/icons/ icon.png, it should generate all the required icons and replace the old ones (see the Tauri icon docs if you need more detail)

Thanks for the detailed instructions. I will try to recreate your idea once I get spare time!

Temanor commented 4 months ago

I agree that the middle bottom one looks best, but I am curious what it would look like with the drop shadow effect and possibly more rounded corners.

27rogi commented 4 months ago

@SpikeHD I got few minutes to make some examples with shadows, some copying original shadow idea and others are more playful with it, to see which is most optimal. Because if some flat element has shadow it might get harder to recognize once element is smaller (for example tray icon / taskbar icon). Also latest one is an experiment which implies idea of more rounded corners by @Temanor, if I understood him correctly 😅

dorion_shadow_all

Temanor commented 4 months ago

Personally, I like the bottom right one the most.

And yes, you understood exactly what I was thinking :)

SpikeHD commented 4 months ago

Looks awesome! I think I lean most towards the top right one, so if you'd like to make a PR with that new icon using those instructions, we can have that in for the next release :+1: