search

StarLabsLtd / firmware

78 stars 5 forks source link

[StarLite Mk V] Need to hold power button to wake up from S3-deep/suspend-to-ram state + power led behaviour #200

Closed rbm78bln closed 4 months ago

rbm78bln commented 4 months ago

Hi there,

I'm not fully sure, whether is was implemented intentionally or not, but when trying to wake the StarLite Mk V from suspend to ram state (s3/deep) while the button is slowly pulsing, you need to press and hold the button for 2-3 secs to actually make it come back to life again. On the other hand it takes just a short press of the button to turn it back on from S4/S5 state and also from S2-idle. Also I don't know whether it was a deliberate decision, to keep the power button fully lit while the device is in S2-idle state.

For my personal taste, it would be nice to have the same wake-up behaviour of the power button for waking up from S5, S3-str, and S2-idle by just a short press of the button as it is done for S5 and S2-idle now. Also it would be nice to be able to differenciate by the power led, whether the device is in S0-working or S2-idle mode. Nevertheless I do like that I am able to tell S2-idle and S3-str apart from looking at the led.

Thanks guys!

PS: firmware version 24.06

Sean-StarLabs commented 4 months ago

Yeah, 2 second delay on the power button when in S0; already changed -- https://github.com/StarLabsLtd/firmware/issues/184

Power LED on means it's in S0 - we don't support MODS.

mixmastamyk commented 1 month ago

What does MODS in all caps mean?

I'm not sure this issue was understood... button still has different behavior in different sleep modes, which is unfortunate.

Sean-StarLabs commented 1 month ago

Modern Standy (S2-idle is part of that)