StefanBruens
commented
7 years ago First, glad you enjoy it 😄
Second, Arduino was developed for small Atmel uCs, and shoehorning it onto other uCs is IMHO not a very good idea:
- "original" ESP boards (ESP-07, ESP-12, ...) don't have any D1,D2, ... pins, but GPIOs 0 to 16, which are clearly labeled on its silkscreen. Using Arduino naming on these boards would be confusing, at least.
- The Atmel HW PWM has different modes, timer predividers, ... whereas this SW PWM has a single mode with coupled PWM frequency and resolution.
- If your ESP board has its GPIOs labeled D1, D2 ... but does not provide any documentation how these are mapped to the ESP8266 GPIOs, you should give the vendor a hit with the cluebat.
So, if you prefer to use D1 as the GPIO name, as it is (mis-)labeled as such on your board, you can just use
#define D1 0
#define D2 1
...in your code and use these as the indices.
If you want to omit the pwm_start() call, just wrap it together with the pwm_set_duty(...) call. Drawback is if you e.g. change 3 channels at the same time, you end up calling pwm_start() three times instead of once.
Hello,
today I replaced my analogWrite() based stuff by you library. All my flicker-issues immediately disappeared - great work!
The only drawback for me is that the use of your library from an Arduino sketch is quite un-intuitive: I use the pre-defined pins D1...D3. I had to find out what the real GIPOs are (5,4 and 0). Then I had to find out the register names (PERIPHS_IO_MUX_GPIO5_U, PERIPHS_IO_MUX_GPIO4_U, PERIPHS_IO_MUX_GPIO0_U)
To write PWM values, I have to use indices (0,1,2), not GPIO pins or D1...D3. And I always have to call pwm_start() after each change.
It would be great if there where a wrapper around your lib, so that it can easily be used as library in arduino. What do you think about this?
Regards, Michael.