StevenBlack / hosts

🔒 Consolidating and extending hosts files from several well-curated sources. Optionally pick extensions for porn, social media, and other categories.
MIT License
26.5k stars 2.2k forks source link

Please add these trackers #2241

Closed ghost closed 1 year ago

ghost commented 1 year ago

From LG WebOS SmartTV: aic-ngfts.lge.com Blocked by notracking: github.com/notracking/hosts-blocklists and 1hosts: https://o0.pages.dev/Pro/adblock.txt

From Google: userlocation.googleapis.com Blocked by 1hosts: https://o0.pages.dev/Pro/adblock.txt

From Shopee: log-collector.shopee.com.br Blocked by 1hosts: https://o0.pages.dev/Pro/adblock.txt Blocked by adguard dns too.

From whatsapp: dit.whatsapp.net Blocked by 1hosts: https://o0.pages.dev/Pro/adblock.txt Blocked by adguard dns too. you are blocking "dit.whatsapp.net.iberostar.com" that is not "dit.whatsapp.net"

welcome[bot] commented 1 year ago

Hello! Thank you for opening your first issue in this repo. It’s people like you who make these host files better!

icedterminal commented 1 year ago

userlocation.googleapis.com is highly unlikely to be added. It has been asked before in the past and denied. Blocking Google's APIs by default is bad in practice. They are widely used and blocking any one of them will result in hundreds if not thousands of complaints because websites/services are broken. Just like how the PiHole community manages a list of domains that simply cannot be blocked, even if they include a tiny amount of tracking. https://discourse.pi-hole.net/t/commonly-whitelisted-domains/212

This domain is largely used on Android to facilitate user location for apps. If blocked, the API cannot gather location and provide this information. This means apps may not work if location is required to function.

icedterminal commented 1 year ago

@StevenBlack pinging you for clarifying these additional domains.

aic-ngfts.lge.com is an ad delivery domain for LG webOS TVs. Luckily I have an LG TV. I have verified that blocking this domain does not interfere with the normal functions of webOS.

log-collector.shopee.com.br is used in the services apps. I don't see it in use on the website. It appears to collect logs at intervals. Used an AVD for this and left it running for hours with the app open, idle. Mostly because I can't read anything in a Brazilian app. What these logs contains I do not know 100%. But it's likely it includes some form of tracking unique information.

dit.whatsapp.net is interesting.

DIT will eventually allow us to obtain usage, reliability, and performance data about our service in a de-identified, privacy-protective way—effectively making WhatsApp even more private. For example, we would be able to understand things like how many people have outdated operating system software or which version of WhatsApp they are running without knowing who those people are. We could also understand if messages have been sent successfully without knowing who sent them.

https://engineering.fb.com/2021/04/16/production-engineering/dit/

Given how WhatsApp is owned by Facebook, you may be doubtful of these statements. I personally do not use WhatsApp so I cannot verify whether or not this domain is critical. Because I am not interested in this service, my input (if it matters) would be to not add this domain until someone else reports or tests it.

ghost commented 1 year ago

@icedterminal Hello, Thank you for your reply.

dit.whatsapp.net is a whatsapp telemetry domain. As whatsapp is closed source, it will never be possible to guarantee that Facebook is speaking the truth in that post you mentioned.I use whatsapp every day as my default messaging application and for several months this domain has been blocked and without any crash or problems sending or receiving messages. AdguardDNS itself blocks it.

aic-ngfts.lge.com Could you do me a favor? Could you prove to me that this domain is indeed LG ads. I have LG, I know it's about ads, but I have another topic open on AdguardDNSFilter's Github and I'm having a hard time convincing them that it's from advertisements, because they don't have an LG webos TV like us. Maybe a printout of packet monitoring, something like that.

Thank you very much

icedterminal commented 1 year ago

aic-ngfts.lge.com Could you do me a favor? Could you prove to me that this domain is indeed LG ads. I have LG, I know it's about ads, but I have another topic open on AdguardDNSFilter's Github and I'm having a hard time convincing them that it's from advertisements, because they don't have an LG webos TV like us. Maybe a printout of packet monitoring, something like that.

I'm not sure why they would give you a hard time. I searched the web and found this: https://discourse.pi-hole.net/t/commonly-blacklisted-domains/305/24 - Then added the variation you have suggested. This domain is just a newer, alternative of ngfts.lge.com. The "tradeoffs" mentioned in the reply are not something I experience. Perhaps that was a 2017 issue, but not now. At least in my case. It literally only made one ad section go away. As the rest were already blocked. Have you not been able to prove this already? All it takes is a photo of the UI with your adblocking enabled vs disabled.

dit.whatsapp.net is a whatsapp telemetry domain. As whatsapp is closed source, it will never be possible to guarantee that Facebook is speaking the truth in that post you mentioned.I use whatsapp every day as my default messaging application and for several months this domain has been blocked and without any crash or problems sending or receiving messages. AdguardDNS itself blocks it.

Understood.

hagezi commented 1 year ago

aic-ngfts.lge.com - Breaks LG Content App Cover Art, see https://github.com/hagezi/dns-blocklists/issues/309#issuecomment-1422014156

blockable: https://github.com/hagezi/dns-data-collection/blob/main/data/native/lg-webos.txt

icedterminal commented 1 year ago

Thanks for your additional feedback @hagezi .

I currently do not experience this. I may sooner or later. In this case it may be best to decline adding it.

stale[bot] commented 1 year ago

This issue has been automatically marked as stale because it has not had recent activity. It will be closed in 14 days if no further activity occurs. Thank you for your contributions.