StevenBlack / hosts

🔒 Consolidating and extending hosts files from several well-curated sources. Optionally pick extensions for porn, social media, and other categories.
MIT License
25.62k stars 2.14k forks source link

notepad.plus #2625

Closed FadeMind closed 1 month ago

FadeMind commented 1 month ago

Ref https://notepad-plus-plus.org/news/help-to-take-down-parasite-site/

StevenBlack commented 1 month ago

Thanks Tomasz!

Merging!

iam-py-test commented 1 month ago

The website clearing discloses the fact that it is not owned by NotePad++'s developer(s), albeit at the bottom of the page where most people never look:

Notepad++ is a trademark of Don Ho. Notepad.plus is not affiliated with, sponsored by, or endorsed by Don Ho in any way. This is an unofficial fan website created for general information/educational purposes only. Any information found in this website is our personal opinions and do not purport to reflect the opinions or views of Don Ho or his representatives. All other trademarks are the property of their respective owners.

The download link goes to the legitimate website, and while the website does have some unsavory trackers (Google, Yandex), the closest thing to an ad is a request to https://mc.yandex.ru/metrika/advert.gif - and even that's just a tracking pixel. There are no visible advertisements that I see (tested in both Firefox and Chrome with uBo and tracking protection disabled). I see no evidence that it is

riddled with malicious advertisements on every page

All of that said, my security software blocklists notepad[.]plus, so maybe they know something I don't. Thanks

FadeMind commented 1 month ago

@iam-py-test @donho is not owner of notepad[.]plus The download link may be swapped with an unsafe one containing malicious code. A few months of gaining trust - oh, after all, it's just a link to Notepad++, and then one line of code is swapped and multiple computers are infected. Who's to blame? There is a note that DonHo is not the owner, but who has time to read the fine print? The site is misleading. Simply put.
In short: Notepad[.]plus domain is a scam and potentially phishing/malware site. No exceptions.

donho commented 1 month ago

More info here: https://community.notepad-plus-plus.org/topic/24001/when-google-is-possessed-by-profit/10?_=1712912762640

iam-py-test commented 1 month ago

With all due respect, currently safe websites should not be blocked based on hypothetical scenarios. There is currently no evidence the website is harmful to users, nor is there any evidence of deceptive advertising (or for that matter any advertising) anywhere on the website. If you have evidence to the contrary, or if the website changes, then it should be blocklisted.

donho is not owner of notepad[.]plus

That does not make it malicious. Nowhere does the website claim to be owned by the actual maintainer of NotePad++, and while the disclaimer should be much more prominent*, it does exist. Moreover, at the risk of using whataboutism, it is no less prominent than other fan websites.

Thank you

* I have contacted the website owner and requested they make it more visible. While I doubt I will receive a response, I believe the website owner should nevertheless be given a chance to rectify this issue.

Edit: it appears I was wrong regarding the advertisements. While there is currently no advertisements on the website, it seems there were ads as recent as 8/4/2024, and that these ads were removed

Edit 2: While I was correct that nowhere on the main page does the website claim to be controlled by the maintainer of NotePad++, they do make the following statement on their blog:

If you don’t have it installed, you can <a href="https://notepad.plus">download it from our website</a>.

One can take this as they will.

FadeMind commented 1 month ago

@iam-py-test

With all due respect, currently safe websites should not be blocked based on hypothetical scenarios.

Owner site think same. Popular Name Mark, Popular Text Editor Tool, "legit" domain name. Possibly RISK and danger is high. Google now blocked it. This is good. No more visible in search results. This is good too. Download aggregators like softsonic using popular names in subdomain, but at end they are adware sites with risky self hosted downloader. Anyone can write a blog, BAD is using similar name. Phishing site work like this. Period.