search

Stormforge-gg / Bugtracker-Fordring

8 stars 3 forks source link

[Core] Loot duplicates #1797

Open Vishiswaz opened 2 years ago

Vishiswaz commented 2 years ago

Description: When a boss drops multiple items, it is currently possible for it to be the same item more than once. This should not be possible.

A boss that drops 2 pieces of loot should drop two different items from its loot table. WoWScrnShot_071722_121936

Aithne99 commented 2 years ago

Ok. And if it drops more than that? 3 items? How about tokens? Because the first statement of your report is blatantly false. What sort of condition do you use to determine whether you should be dupe-protected, if you should be at all, and why is it so fucking important to be dupe-protected in the first place?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o-BdYY5gAhE&t=330s

Godmatik commented 2 years ago

I am fairly certain dupe protection is present in dungeons, this was the case in TBC classic and I would be surprised if Wrath suddenly changed that. I do agree with you though that dupes should exist in raids (because dupes happen in TBC classic raids currently)

I don't know the current state or progression of Wrath classic beta but I'm sure we'll find out soon either way...

Vishiswaz commented 2 years ago

If it was that way in TBC Classic I can't imagine them removing dupes protection in WotLK Classic.

Vishiswaz commented 2 years ago

Either way, duplicates are dumb in most cases and tbh I really don't care if it's blizzlike, it's an easy quality of life improvement you can make for the players and lots of other servers do it, as well, so it's not like it'd be out of the norm. Like having dungeon finder enabled before 3.3. Except that actually has a lot of cons no one wants to talk about lol

Godmatik commented 2 years ago

sorry if what I said was confusing, I meant to say I agree with you that duplicates in dungeons should not be a thing. Only should exist in raids. That's how it is in classic TBC - and I would be surprised if it suddenly changed in Wrath.

kekkerina commented 2 years ago

i did nefarian and he dropped 2 heads lmfao

Aithne99 commented 2 years ago

Dungeons are "dupe protected" because the bosses that drop two items drop them from two separate pools, one rare and one epic, and those items cannot be the same, obviously.