SupposeNot / RAMP

Research Assistant for Maps and Polytopes
4 stars 0 forks source link

Erroneous citation for SatisfiesWeakPathIntersectionProperty #183

Closed SupposeNot closed 1 year ago

SupposeNot commented 1 year ago

So... I wanted to read some more about this test involved in testing a maniplex for polytonality, but the cited paper ([GH18] Gleason, I. and Hubard, I., Products of abstract polytopes, Journal of Combinatorial Theory, Series A, Elsevier {BV}, 157 (2018), 287--320.) does not appear to contain any reference to this property... sooo... where does it come from?

SupposeNot commented 1 year ago

Poking around, there's a paper which seems more on point, but doesn't seem to have exactly the right thing in it: [1] J. Garza-Vargas and I. Hubard. Polytopality of maniplexes. Discrete Math., 341(7):2068–2079, 2018. This has several path intersection properties, but none called the WPIP.

CunningGabe commented 1 year ago

What happened here is that in a preprint of their paper, they had two properties: the Weak PIP and the PIP. Later, they changed it, so the old WPIP is now called the PIP, and the old PIP is now called the Strong PIP. So we should rename the function(s) and then cite Polytopality of Maniplexes.

SupposeNot commented 1 year ago

I'll take care of it then...

SupposeNot commented 1 year ago

Handled in c30702c.