Closed sydb closed 2 years ago
With @sydb @HelenaSabel and @npcole : We found that if we change line 2018 or odd2odd.xsl from:
<xsl:for-each select="tei:constraintSpec">
to:
<xsl:for-each select="descendant::tei:constraintSpec">
we get a change in behaviour -- processing does find the constraintSpecs -- but the original problem is not solved by this alone.
We (the Stylesheets group) have just discovered the problem (thanks to @HelenaSabel :-) — the key ../@ident||'_'||@ident
does the wrong thing in some cases.
So our proposed solution is to just use @ident
instead. There are a few cases where this will fail, because we have used the same identifier on two or more <constraintSpec>
s:
5 abstractModel-structure-l
3 spanTo
3 spanTo_fr
2 abstractModel-structure-p
So we suggest those 13 just get re-named, so we can use just @ident
. This solution also requires that users always use unique constraintSpec/@ident
, so probably a <constraintSpec>
to enforce that is a good idea!
Blocked until the discussion on TEI ticket 2223 is closed.
See TEI issue 2223 and the corresponding PR.
Hmmm … is it better to write that as
See /TEIC/TEI/issues/2223 and the corresponding PR, /TEIC/TEI/pull/2224.
? The former looks nicer, but the latter gives you pop-ups.
One would think this would be easy. Just
<constraintSpec module="[module]" ident="[ident]" sceme="schematron" mode="delete"/>
should do it, eh? A bit weird that@scheme
is required, but no big deal.No such luck. The big deal is that it does not work. Nor does most any other method I tried. According to my little test ODD (which is attached to this ticket with an extra .txt extension), one can delete a
<constraintSpec>
from a class by specifying the deletion or change (to an empty<constraintSpec>
or<constraint>
) in a<classSpec mode="change">
; and one can delete a<constraintSpec>
from an element only if"replace"
ed with an empty one.I do not think this is the right state of affairs. I think that the whole point of being in att.identifiable is to be deleted or over-ridden.