the definition of <desc> in Appendix C of the guidelines is (description) contains a short description of the purpose, function, or use of its parent element, or when the parent is a documentation element, describes or defines the object being documented. (see https://tei-c.org/release/doc/tei-p5-doc/en/html/ref-desc.html)
Anyway, on the element page the "Example of a desc element in a non-documentation element" (the second example) is:
This IMO does not seem to be consistent with the definition: in my view, this <desc> does not contain "a short description of the purpose, function, or use" of its <terrain> parent.
the definition of
<desc>
in Appendix C of the guidelines is(description) contains a short description of the purpose, function, or use of its parent element, or when the parent is a documentation element, describes or defines the object being documented.
(see https://tei-c.org/release/doc/tei-p5-doc/en/html/ref-desc.html)Anyway, on the element page the "Example of a
desc
element in a non-documentation element" (the second example) is:This IMO does not seem to be consistent with the definition: in my view, this
<desc>
does not contain "a short description of the purpose, function, or use" of its<terrain>
parent.Compare the use of
<desc>
as a child of<gap>
at https://tei-c.org/release/doc/tei-p5-doc/en/html/CO.html#index-egXML-d54e34303 (where it states the encoder's rationale for using the parent element in this specific occasion), which in my view would make a better example than the Kerguelen Islands one: