TEJA831 / Project4

0 stars 0 forks source link

Code Review for Adding dynamic switching of the views #12

Open TEJA831 opened 1 year ago

TEJA831 commented 1 year ago

Code Review Story: Dynamic View Switching Implementation (Problem 4)

Summary: This code review story evaluates the implementation of dynamic view switching in p4.html and p4.jsx, as outlined in Problem 4 of the project. The primary objective is to allow users to switch between the Example and States components using a button. The review covers various aspects, including code structure, functionality, webpack configuration, and overall code quality.

Review Comments:

  1. File Structure and Naming:

    • Confirm that both p4.html and p4.jsx have been correctly created and named as per the problem statement. Verify that the file structure adheres to project conventions.
  2. Webpack Configuration:

    • Ensure that webpack.config.js has been appropriately modified to build a file named "compiled/p4.bundle.js." Confirm that this configuration is correctly integrated with the build process.
  3. Code Structure:

    • Examine the code structure in p4.jsx. Ensure that it adheres to best practices, such as consistent indentation, clear separation of components, and modularization.
  4. View Switching Functionality:

    • Verify that the dynamic view switching functionality is correctly implemented. Check that there are buttons above each view component (Example and States) that allow users to toggle between them.
    • Test the functionality of the switching buttons. Ensure that when one view is displayed, clicking the corresponding button correctly hides it and displays the other view.
  5. Component Organization:

    • Check how the Example and States components are organized within p4.jsx. Ensure that they are properly defined and structured to maintain code readability and maintainability.

Conclusion: The dynamic view switching implementation appears promising and aligned with the requirements outlined in Problem 4. However, a thorough review, testing, and verification are essential to ensure that the functionality works as expected and that the codebase is of high quality. Additionally, the webpack configuration and file naming should be confirmed to meet project specifications.

Overall, this code review story concludes that the dynamic view switching feature is on the right track, but further testing and refinements may be required before considering this implementation complete.