Code Review for Problem 2: Creating a States View Component
Summary:
This code review focuses on the implementation of the States View Component, as described in Problem 2. The primary objective is to create a ReactJS component that displays a list of states containing a given substring, updates the list dynamically as the user types, and handles various scenarios such as empty substring and no matching states. The review covers code structure, functionality, styling, and overall code quality.
Review Comments:
Component Creation and Structure:
Confirm the creation of the States component in a file named States.jsx. Ensure that it is correctly defined as a ReactJS component class, adhering to the required naming convention.
Integration with Web App:
Verify that the States component has been successfully integrated into the web app, as indicated by the inclusion of "compiled/p2.bundle.js" in p2.html. Ensure that the integration is smooth and does not lead to any conflicts.
Input Field and Substring Handling:
Assess the implementation of the input field that accepts the substring. Test whether the input field updates the state list as the user types, and that it correctly handles case insensitivity.
Verify that the input field clears when the substring is empty and that the state list resets to displaying all states.
Display of Matching States:
Check if the State component displays an HTML list of states in alphabetical order based on the given substring. Ensure that the list updates automatically as the user types.
Test for accuracy in filtering and sorting states based on the substring provided.
Display of Substring Element:
Confirm the implementation of a separate element to display the substring used for filtering. Verify that this element accurately reflects the substring input by the user.
Handling No Matching States:
Test the behavior when there are no matching states for the given substring. Ensure that the web page displays a clear message indicating this fact, rather than showing an empty list.
CSS Styling:
Review the CSS styles defined in States.css. Ensure that the styles are well-organized and enhance the visual appeal of the state list and input field. Check for any potential styling issues that may affect readability or usability.
Conclusion:
The States View Component implementation appears to be on the right track, focusing on the dynamic filtering and display of states based on a given substring. The review aims to ensure that the component functions correctly, is visually appealing, and follows code quality and documentation standards.
Overall, this code review story concludes that the States View Component aligns with the project requirements. Any identified issues or improvements should be addressed to achieve a robust and user-friendly component.
Code Review for Problem 2: Creating a States View Component
Summary: This code review focuses on the implementation of the States View Component, as described in Problem 2. The primary objective is to create a ReactJS component that displays a list of states containing a given substring, updates the list dynamically as the user types, and handles various scenarios such as empty substring and no matching states. The review covers code structure, functionality, styling, and overall code quality.
Review Comments:
Component Creation and Structure:
Integration with Web App:
Input Field and Substring Handling:
Display of Matching States:
Display of Substring Element:
Handling No Matching States:
CSS Styling:
Conclusion: The States View Component implementation appears to be on the right track, focusing on the dynamic filtering and display of states based on a given substring. The review aims to ensure that the component functions correctly, is visually appealing, and follows code quality and documentation standards.
Overall, this code review story concludes that the States View Component aligns with the project requirements. Any identified issues or improvements should be addressed to achieve a robust and user-friendly component.