search

TGX-Android / Telegram-X

The main repository of Telegram X — official alternative Telegram client for Android.
https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=org.thunderdog.challegram
GNU General Public License v3.0
3.53k stars 558 forks source link

Multiple topics in a group not appearing as separate #360

Open GameEntity903 opened 1 year ago

GameEntity903 commented 1 year ago

  1. Telegram X 0.25.6.1620-arm64-v8a (66e9c711) TDLib: 1.8.12 (tdlib/td@b5fe088) Android: 11 (30) Device: Xiaomi Xiaomi Mi A3 (qssi-user 11 RKQ1.200903.002 V12.0.26.0.RFQMIXM) Screen: 1475x720 (density: 2.0, fps: 60.000004) Build: Xiaomi/laurel_sprout/laurel_sprout:11/RKQ1.200903.002/V12.0.26.0.RFQMIXM:user/release-keys Package: org.thunderdog.challegram Locale: en_IN (app: en) Installer: Google Play APK Fingerprint: 66:46:21:34:34:5a:6a:da:c3:c1:d5:ae:a9:ce:f0:42:1b:7c:ab:68

  2. Expected Screenshot_20230323-082414~2 The two different topics should be split into two different chats like it is in Telegram Main.

    Observed Screenshot_20230323-082409~2 All the messages are viewed in the same group topic.

  3. Telegram X 0.25.6.1620-arm64-v8a

GameEntity903 commented 1 year ago

As a side note, Topics for groups can not be created in Telegram X. Are Topics as a whole not supported in Telegram X?

RememberTheAir commented 1 year ago

Topics are not yet supported in TGX

Anisotropic commented 1 year ago

When topics would be supported?

urkbio commented 1 year ago

When topics would be supported?

I also waiting for this

fkarg commented 1 year ago

Still true for version 0.25.9.1637 (f3309e4d), build from 2023-06-09

RememberTheAir commented 1 year ago

it's pointless to point out that topics are not supported by builds that do not explicitly mention topics support in their changelog :/

fkarg commented 1 year ago

The intention was to 1) draw some attention to it (seems to have worked perfectly ;)) 2) provide information for people looking into this later that nothing had changed in the time between the opening of the issue and my comment 3) be this a subtle variant of 'I'd appreciate it if this were to be fixed' and 4) to receive notifications on progress.

sussum2432 commented 1 year ago

Still not working

Mechite commented 1 year ago

See #345 - They're going to close your issue at some point.

SimoLRepo commented 8 months ago

+1

When will this feature be added?

Ramshu commented 7 months ago

+1 It's an essential feature, I hope you support it soon.

Mechite commented 7 months ago

Please react with the thumbs up instead of posting +1s

SimoLRepo commented 7 months ago

Please react with the thumbs up instead of posting +1s

@Mechite Both. There is actually a reason for this. Adding the "+1" has two advantages:

RememberTheAir commented 7 months ago

The post is shown among recently edited discussions.

and why would that be desired?

More users are shown, so that the level of interest in that feature is understood

The developer is perfectly aware that this is an highly demanded feature and that TGX will be unusable for many people until topics are fully supported. Adding noise to this issue is not going to accelerate the development, and one might also argue that pushing it with recurring useless pings might have the opposite effect

Mechite commented 7 months ago

Not a huge problem or something I really think giving designs for how this would be implemented is probably what they desire Flooding the thread makes it harder for anyone who does such a contribution to be seen

SimoLRepo commented 7 months ago

@RememberTheAir I agree with you but liking the comment of @Mechite has no benefit... Maybe it would be desirable to add likes in the first comment, @Mechite maybe he meant exactly that.

MartinX3 commented 7 months ago

A year later and no topics. I switched to the open source client "Forkgram" installed via F-Droid. Topics are working and the app is fast.

SimoLRepo commented 7 months ago

A year later and no topics. I switched to the open source client "Forkgram" installed via F-Droid. Topics are working and the app is fast.

You are right, unfortunately Forkgram has the same lock-locked invasive premium features via padlock icons as the classic version. The Telegram X version while having the premium features does not annoy the user. For the time being, I use Telegram FOSS 🙁. I still trust the topic implementation.

MartinX3 commented 7 months ago

A year later and no topics. I switched to the open source client "Forkgram" installed via F-Droid. Topics are working and the app is fast.

You are right, unfortunately Forkgram has the same lock-locked invasive premium features via padlock icons as the classic version. The Telegram X version while having the premium features does not annoy the user. For the time being, I use Telegram FOSS ☹. I still trust the topic implementation.

That's true, because it's a fork of the Telegram App. But it's due to the maintainer of this fork as no time to hide the premium stuff. See https://github.com/forkgram/TelegramAndroid/issues/230

But on the other side he's fast with rebasing Forkgram on the newest Telegram App Version and also he keeps his commit history clean as a rebase on the latest Forkgram commits.

SimoLRepo commented 7 months ago

That's true, because it's a fork of the Telegram App. But it's due to the maintainer of this fork as no time to hide the premium stuff.

But on the other side he's fast with rebasing Forkgram on the newest Telegram App Version and also he keeps his commit history clean as a rebase on the latest Forkgram commits.

@MartinX3 Exactly, maybe I'll go back to using Forkgram too. Telegram FOSS seems a little behind on the versions. It's a real shame that labels remain enabled in saved messages, as indicated in the issue opened by me that you mentioned. Thank you.

MartinX3 commented 7 months ago

Woopsi, I didn't see that it was your issue ticket. :D

It seems that the FOSS and Fork guys should merge their forks and work together. Both don't have much time.

t0ma5 commented 6 months ago

The lack of Multiple topics in groups is a real deal-breaker :(

dsg0tm commented 5 months ago

Same here. I need to revert back to regular telegram app due to this.

aliuq commented 4 months ago

Looking forward to this feature very much ☺️

maximlunegov commented 2 months ago

Still waiting for multiple topics.

t0ma5 commented 2 months ago

Still waiting...

sussum2432 commented 2 months ago

This app is almost useless at this point , still no topics?

On Tue, Aug 13, 2024, 23:35 t0ma5 @.***> wrote:

Still waiting...

— Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/TGX-Android/Telegram-X/issues/360#issuecomment-2287092607, or unsubscribe https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AVPLPLVGXKRQQGDQSZVEETTZRJUZRAVCNFSM6AAAAAAWETY226VHI2DSMVQWIX3LMV43OSLTON2WKQ3PNVWWK3TUHMZDEOBXGA4TENRQG4 . You are receiving this because you commented.Message ID: @.***>