search

Taiko2k / Tauon

The music player of today! :city_sunrise:
https://tauonmusicbox.rocks
GNU General Public License v3.0
1.64k stars 65 forks source link

Tauon scrobbles all plays twice #566

Closed gigawhitlocks closed 2 years ago

gigawhitlocks commented 2 years ago

This may only happen when using an Airsonic-compatible server, I don't know. It also may only occur with the Airsonic-compatible server that I use, Navidrome.

But basically what the title says: everything gets scrobbled twice to Last.FM.

I won't open any more issues against Tauon unless you request. Too many bugs to report them all; going to go back to using Clementine unless you're interested in reports for the rest of the bugs I have encountered, but regardless I can't use a media player that is going to mess up my scrobbles any more than Tauon already has.

Taiko2k commented 2 years ago

Is it the case that you enabled lastfm on both Tauon and Navidrome? This situation would cause double scrobbles.

gigawhitlocks commented 2 years ago

Navidrome's scrobble feature is for the web UI only: https://github.com/navidrome/navidrome/issues/18#issuecomment-719127076

I do have scrobbles enabled in the Navidrome UI but other clients (DSub, Clementine) do not cause double scrobbles even though I also have those clients configured to scrobble directly.

deluan commented 2 years ago

Hey, Navidrome developer here. Let me clarify it: If you enable Last.fm scrobbling in Navidrome's Personal settings, it will by default enable scrobbling for all players that call the /scrobble endpoint, not only the web UI. You are probably not getting it from DSub because you need to enable it in DSub to send the scrobble to the server

So, if you have it enabled in the Personal settings, and if Tauon calls the /scrobble?submission=true AND sends the scrobble directly to Last.fm, you'll see double scrobbles. You have two options: Disable Tauon sending scrobbles directly to Last.fm (if that's an option), or disable the Last.fm scrobbling only for Tauon in Navidrome's Players view.

I hope this is not confusing to follow. I'll write a page to better explain how scrobble works with Navidrome and Subsonic clients, because the Subsonic API calling it "scrobble" makes it very confusing.

gigawhitlocks commented 2 years ago

You are probably not getting it from DSub because you need to enable it in DSub to send the scrobble to the server

ohhhhhh.. shoot, I am so sorry @Taiko2k for the bad bug report; thank you for the clarity @deluan ; closing this