TeamVanced / VancedManager

Vanced Installer
GNU General Public License v3.0
8.25k stars 1.14k forks source link

Make the version(s) visible again #535

Open stdedos opened 3 years ago

stdedos commented 3 years ago

Please check all boxes below by replacing space with x

Suggestion:

While the new expandable card UI is nice, it is boring to have to extend the cards to see if there is a new version.

I'd rather extend the description instead (which can be auto-extended, if the app is not installed - if I installed it, I "probably" know what that app is doing)

X1nto commented 3 years ago

Thanks for the suggestion, we'll keep that in mind

frenchiveruti commented 3 years ago

I agree, new design although nice, is not really that much useful.
Yes, I admit I open the manager only when I'm notified of an update, but still.

X1nto commented 3 years ago

What do you think about this? Basically, the layout is always expanded and descriptions are removed as they're not really needed image

stdedos commented 3 years ago

"Sure", but you have too much wasted vertical space on the right.

Why don't you have a layout like: Icon, Name/CurrentVersion, buttons

and add the "Latest" version on the bottom as a full row (if there is one or "Unavailable").

Descriptions can be shown only when it's needed - i.e. when the app is not installed. 😝

X1nto commented 3 years ago

"Sure", but you have too much wasted vertical space on the fight.

Why don't you have a layout like: Icon, Name/CurrentVersion, buttons

and add the "Latest" version on the bottom as a full row (if there is one or "Unavailable").

Descriptions can be shown only when it's needed - i.e. when the app is not installed. 😝

This was just a quick mockup I made under 15 minutes just to show off what I had in mind with always expanded layout, it'll be further improved

frenchiveruti commented 3 years ago

I have an improvement but I suck at doing graphics.
What about colors? Green = Released matches downloaded version Yellow = Newer release available Red = Not downloaded.

Because to be honest, as a "normie" I don't care about the version, if I want to see "what's new" I'll probably check the changelogs anyway.

That way you can save space or come up with some more creative approach.
Also, about the "names".
Saying "Youtube Vanced" is kinda... redundant don't you think?
Why not just leave "Vanced"
"Vanced Music"
And "MicroG" for each of them?

stdedos commented 3 years ago

What about colors? Green = Released matches downloaded version Yellow = Newer release available Red = Not downloaded.

Too strong, and red is an error in general in UX ...

Why not just leave "Vanced"

The application's name is "Vanced Manager", and you want to leave the "Vanced" out of "YouTube Vanced"?

Anyway, IMHO it's not an option (or necessary even).

frenchiveruti commented 3 years ago

You seem to be very critical but lacking in the ideas department.

stdedos commented 3 years ago

You seem to be very critical but lacking in the ideas department.

Both true! And I consider the first one to be a compliment; thank you! 😄 (PS: I hope my response did not come off as offensive to you, and hence the response)