TechAndCheck / tech-and-check-alerts

Daily tip sheet for fact checkers
MIT License
13 stars 6 forks source link

Tracking list of attribution errors #167

Open ericaryan opened 5 years ago

ericaryan commented 5 years ago

From Monday's test email:

S. RAMPELL (CNN): And what's interesting is that If Trump actually thinks that there is a conspiracy happening to fake these numbers or to, you know, to fake forecasts, which a number of reporters, including Maggie Haberman and colleagues of mine at "The Washington Post" have reported, you know, the real question is, does he really think that nine other country statisticians are in on the conspiracy too because nine other countries are also -- are either in recession or on the verge of recession, and that's one of the major risks here.

S. RAMPELL should be CATHERINE RAMPELL

Possibly caused by this?

BERMAN: So job numbers were -- you know, economic numbers were phony in the past. Now they're real. Now they're going back to being phony. You could see it in Sean's face. He knows it's B.**S.

RAMPELL**: Yes, of course he does.

reefdog commented 5 years ago

From today's test email:

ACOSTA (CNN): The president is out with a new unproven conspiracy theory accusing Google of manipulating more than two million votes in 2016, adding, his victory was even bigger than thought.

The line preceding it in the transcript is (END VIDEO CLIP), but also, the original instance of Jim Acosta was like this: JIM ACOSTA, CNN CHIEF White House CORRESPONDENT. I don't think we account for lowercase letters in the speaker.

ericaryan commented 5 years ago

This one was from Friday:

MEYER (CNN): The two biggest reasons we decided to make this move, that really troubled me, one is that every year since I've been a restauranteur in a tipping situation, the gap between what a tipped employee and someone who is legally not eligible to accept tips, also known primarily as cooks, the gap has grown and grown and grown, probably by 300 percent.

http://www.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/1908/14/ampr.01.html

Original instance was DANNY MEYER, FOUNDER & CEO, UNION SQUARE HOSPITALITY GROUP

Seems like there were some weird line breaks happening in the transcript that might have played a role? Not sure.

reefdog commented 5 years ago

First reference:

HARRY ENTEN, CNN SENIOR POLITICAL WRITER & ANALYST

Newsletter:

ENTEN (CNN): And what we see is that those under the age of 45, sharing the positions on your issues is most important, 56 percent to 41 percent, on a strong chance of beating Donald Trump.

Transcript:

BOLDUAN: I want to know where you want to take this. I am constantly interested in the question of, what matters most to you. Is it a candidate that agrees with you on the issues or is it a candidate that you think can beat Donald Trump? Where do things --

(CROSSTALK)

ENTEN: Yes. So basically, what we see is we see this big divide by age on this question. And what we see is that those under the age of 45, sharing the positions on your issues is most important, 56 percent to 41 percent, on a strong chance of beating Donald Trump.

reefdog commented 5 years ago

First reference:

JIM ACOSTA, CNN CHIEF White House CORRESPONDENT

Newsletter:

ACOSTA (CNN): One of the president's top advisers Larry Kudlow insists there is no recession to fear but Kudlow is defending his own record of economic predictions, busted one year after the 2008 financial crisis Kudlow wrote in the National Review "you can't call it a recession.): One of the president's top advisers Larry Kudlow insists there is no recession to fear but Kudlow is defending his own record of economic predictions, busted one year after the 2008 financial crisis Kudlow wrote in the National Review "you can't call it a recession.

Transcript:

UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE: Is that why --

KUDLOW: -- what's wrong with a little optimism?

(END VIDEO CLIP)

ACOSTA: One of the president's top advisers Larry Kudlow insists there is no recession to fear but Kudlow is defending his own record of economic predictions, busted one year after the 2008 financial crisis Kudlow wrote in the National Review "you can't call it a recession. This sort of fiscal and monetary coordination will continue the Bush boom for years to come.


Newsletter:

ACOSTA (CNN): As for the president's bogus conspiracy theory that Google manipulated votes in the 2016 election, Hillary Clinton has responded on Twitter noting the claim has been debunked.

Transcript:

TRUMP: Fox has changed. And my worst polls have always been from Fox, there's something going on at Fox, I'll tell you right now and I'm not happy with it.

(END VIDEO CLIP)

ACOSTA: As for the president's bogus conspiracy theory that Google manipulated votes in the 2016 election, Hillary Clinton has responded on Twitter noting the claim has been debunked. [03:05:01] Jim Acosta, CNN, the White House.

ericaryan commented 5 years ago

These seem to be issues with parentheticals:

Today's newsletter:

(CNN): : If 250 kilos or just over 550 pounds is accurate, that's well over $10 million at global market prices, all from one single dug hole.

Transcript:

[11:10:00] (voice-over): If 250 kilos or just over 550 pounds is accurate, that's well over $10 million at global market prices, all from one single


Newsletter:

SOARES (CNN): If 250 kilos or just over 550 pounds is accurate, that's well over $10 million at global market prices, all from one single dark hole.

Transcript:

UNIDENTIFIED MALE (ON SCREEN CAPTIONS): When you're working a large section of the mine, we could dig as many as 50 or 60 bags.

SOARES: Everywhere you looked speckles shimmer from above.

This mine has been so productive for them because they have got 250 kilos of gold out of this mine, just to give you a sense really why it's called "the millionaire's mine."

If 250 kilos or just over 550 pounds is accurate, that's well over $10 million at global market prices, all from one single dark hole. There are dozens around as thousands within Venezuela's mining ark.

First reference:

(BEGIN VIDEOTAPE) ISA SOARES, CNN ANCHOR & CORRESPONDENT

ericaryan commented 5 years ago

I don't have any guesses for this one.

Newsletter:

S. ATWOOD (CNN): The U.S. has been allowed to use strategic bases in Greenland since the Cold War, that allows the U.S. to listen in on Russia and other things across the Arctic and the Danish troops have fought alongside U.S. soldiers in both Iraq and Afghanistan; 43 Danish troops died in Afghanistan fighting alongside U.S. soldiers.

Transcript:

But it is important to point out that Denmark is an important ally of the U.S.

ATWOOD: Exactly right. So President Trump canceled this trip via tweet to Denmark because the prime minister, as you said, called it absurd that the president wanted to buy Greenland.

But the important thing here is that both Danish officials and folks who live there are feeling a little bit like they've been treated unfairly here because they have stood next to the U.S. for years, especially when it comes to national security.

The U.S. has been allowed to use strategic bases in Greenland since the Cold War, that allows the U.S. to listen in on Russia and other things across the Arctic and the Danish troops have fought alongside U.S. soldiers in both Iraq and Afghanistan; 43 Danish troops died in Afghanistan fighting alongside U.S. soldiers.

First reference:

KYLIE ATWOOD, CNN NATIONAL SECURITY ANALYST

reefdog commented 5 years ago

Today's problems:

Newsletter:

[FMR. BETO O'ROURKE (CNN)](): You know the first place that I went to after spending nearly two weeks in El Paso following that shooting was Jackson, Mississippi, to visit small communities in that state that have been subject to the largest single state employment ICE raid in the history of this country.

Transcript context:

…What do you think?

O'ROURKE: You know the first place that I went to after spending…

First reference:

FMR. REP. BETO O'ROURKE (D-TX), PRESIDENTIAL CANDIDATE


Newsletter:

(CNN): : If 250 kilos or just over 550 pounds is accurate, that's well over $10 million at global market prices, all from one single dug hole.

Transcript context:

…why it's called the Millionaire's Mine.

(voice-over): If 250 kilos or just over 550 pounds is accurate…

First reference:

ISA SOARES, CNN CORRESPONDENT (voice-over)


Newsletter:

BUTTIGIEG (CNN): For example, it may be possible, without even amending the Constitution, to adjust the structure of the Supreme Court so that it had 15 members but only 10 of them were appointed politically, the other were rotated up from the appellate bench and could only be seated by unanimous consensus among the other 10.

Transcript context:

…What would that solve and what do you envision?

BUTTIGIEG: Well, the problem that we have to solve is that the Supreme Court…

First reference:

MAYOR PETE BUTTIGIEG (D-SOUTH BEND, IN) PRESIDENTIAL CANDIDATE


Newsletter:

SANGER (CNN): Well, it's interesting that the one issue that the president put out for the G-7 ahead of time, at least publicly, was the question of whether or not Russia would be readmitted, which he said he wanted to do, without having to resolve the reason that Russia was disinvited from the G-7 meetings to begin with, which was the annexation of Crimea, which the president referred to as a result of President Obama's team (ph).

Transcript context:

…I mean, is he acknowledging defeat before they even begin?

SANGER: Well, it's interesting that the one issue that the president…

First reference:

DAVID SANGER, CNN POLITICAL & NATIONAL SECURITY ANALYST

(I think we can now assume ampersands are not accounted for.)


Newsletter:

MCENANY (CNN): Lowest unemployment rate for Black Americans, Hispanic- Americans, generational lows in unemployment, great productivity report, wages growing at the fastest pace in a decade, and twice as fast for low and middle income Americans, no arguing with the Trump economy.

Transcript context:

…one day apart, what happened?

MCENANY: Well it's a debate within the administration…

First reference:

KAYLEIGH MCENANY, TRUMP 2020 PRESIDENTIAL CAMPAIGN NATIONAL PRESS SECRETARY, FORMER RNC SPOKESWOMAN


Newsletter:

ENTEN (CNN): Kamala Harris jumped all the way up from 8 percent to 27 percent.

Transcript context:

…What does it mean?

ENTEN: Yes. I mean I think one of the first things we should look at…

First reference:

So, let's get to the Wizard of Odds. He's been digging in for us. Inslee getting out, look Harry, not a huge surprise. HARRY ENTEN, CNN POLITICS SENIOR WRITER & ANALYST: No.

reefdog commented 5 years ago

Newsletter:

DEAN on EARLY START (CNN): Brazil's own space agency says there are 85 percent more fires burning in the country this year than last, and that more than half of those are in the Amazon.

First reference:

[05:00:00] JESSICA DEAN, CO-ANCHOR, EARLY START

reefdog commented 5 years ago

Newsletter:

on CONNECT THE WORLD (CNN): And now a new poll has just been released showing that Bolsonaro's approval rating has plummeted to 29 percent here in August from 40 percent in February.

First reference:

SHASTA DARLINGTON, JOURNALIST (via Skype)


Newsletter:

HELFENBEIN on AT THIS HOUR (CNN): In America, we have like 329 million people and, in China, they have 1.4 billion people.

First reference:

RICK HELFENBEIN, PRESIDENT & CEO, AMERICAN FOOTWEAR & APPAREL ASSOCIATION


Newsletter:

STRONG on NEW DAY (CNN): And the evidence is that those medications were rarely diverted, rarely abused and amounted to less than 1 percent of all the opioid medications prescribed in Oklahoma.

First reference:

SABRINA STRONG, ATTORNEY FOR JOHNSON & JOHNSON


There was also a claim attributed to "CHURCH" but that was because the transcript itself never provided a first reference.

ericaryan commented 5 years ago

Tech & Check Alerts: CNN 08/31/19

BRIGGS: 4 on EARLY START (CNN): Direct purchases totaled $21.3 billion in the first half of the year, down more than 40 percent. http://transcripts.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/1908/30/es.02.html

Apparently the anchor saying the time was the issue? BRIGGS: 4:57, a check on CNN Business this morning [how the attribution with the relevant quote began]

First ref: DAVE BRIGGS, CNN ANCHOR: A state of emergency across Florida.

--

KIRBY on CNN RIGHT NOW (CNN): He presided over one of the largest -- the largest-ever historical budget that DOD has ever been presented, more than $700 billion.

http://transcripts.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/1908/28/crn.02.html

First ref: REAR ADM. JOHN KIRBY, CNN MILITARY & DIPLOMATIC ANALYST: I thought it was very thoughtful, candid.

--

HILL on CNN NEWSROOM (CNN): Yet, years before, the company and three executives had already pleaded guilty in federal court to misleading and defrauding doctors and consumers about Oxycontin and agreed to pay more than a $600 million fine.

http://transcripts.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/1908/29/cnr.17.html

ERICA HILL, CNN ANCHOR/CORRESPONDENT (voice-over): It's a story of pain, addiction and enormous profits.

ericaryan commented 5 years ago

Tech & Check Alerts: CNN 09/01/19

CABRERA on CNN NEWSROOM (CNN): Twenty-one million residents, plus countless tourists, in the path of a monster storm, already a category 3.

http://transcripts.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/1908/30/cnr.06.html

First ref: [14:30:00] ANA CABRERA KEILAR, CNN HOST: The city of Miami is so concerned about scooters becoming projectiles during the storm that the city has now ordered companies to take them off the street.

--

MARIOTTI on CNN NEWSROOM (CNN): Comey then was fired under false pretenses, based on a memo that was written by Rosenstein that was for a reason that turned out not to be the actual reason Comey was fired.

http://transcripts.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/1908/30/cnr.06.html

First ref: RENATO MARIOTTI, CNN LEGAL ANALYST; Yes, I don't think there's really any question that that was where they had to go.

ericaryan commented 5 years ago

Tech & Check Alerts: CNN, Twitter 09/03/19

BRIGGS: 4 on EARLY START (CNN): 16 Eastern Time in the U.S., the China trade war has escalated again, 15 percent tariffs on estimated $110 billion worth of Chinese goods kicked in on Sunday.

http://transcripts.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/1909/02/es.01.html

First ref: DAVE BRIGGS, CNN ANCHOR: Catastrophic hurricane Dorian steam rolls the Bahamas.

--

BRIGGS on EARLY START (CNN): The U.S.-China trade war has escalated again, 15 percent tariffs on an estimated $110 billion worth of Chinese goods kicked in Sunday.

BRIGGS on EARLY START (CNN): Since reliable data began back in the 1960s, Dorian will be crawling along at 3 miles per hour over the next two days -- a walking pace for most of us.

http://transcripts.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/1909/02/es.03.html

First ref: DAVE BRIGGS, CO-ANCHOR, EARLY START: Continues right now.

reefdog commented 5 years ago

Tech & Check Alerts: CNN, Twitter 09/03/19:

MAYOR KATHY MEEHAN (R-MELBOURNE on CNN NEWSROOM (CNN): We have 14 emergency shelters that are open, and Uber is offering free rides to approved shelters up to $20.

First reference:

MAYOR KATHY MEEHAN (R-MELBOURNE, FL.)

Possible cause: comma and period in parenthetical?

ericaryan commented 5 years ago

REED on CNN NEWSROOM (CNN): Georgia Department of Natural Resources,, the Coast Guard air station in Savannah as well as the air facility in Charleston, all of them were involved in pulling the 20 people off of that vessel that have been save so far.

http://transcripts.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/1909/08/cnr.02.html

First ref: CAPT. JOHN REED, U.S. COAST GUARD COMMANDER (through phone): Good afternoon, Fredricka.

ericaryan commented 5 years ago

Tech & Check Alerts: CNN, Twitter 09/10/19

WOOD on NEW DAY SUNDAY (CNN): As far as long-term recovery -- I mean, one of your previous guests mentioned that, you know, some communities 90 percent of the homes are destroyed.

First ref: JAKE WOOD, CO-FOUNDER AND CEO OF TEAM RUBICON (on the phone): Good morning from Abaco.

ericaryan commented 5 years ago

Tech & Check Alerts: CNN, Twitter 09/11/19

BAN on CNN NEWSROOM (CNN): I am urging President Trump to implement a pledge between his presidential campaign that he would invest $ 1 trillion to beef up the resilient infrastructure according to American Association -- American society of Engineering, if this resilient infrastructure is not well funded, at least 2.5 billion million job losses and they will be if a list of a $4 trillion dollars gap in national GDP.

http://transcripts.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/1909/10/cnr.18.html

First ref: BAN KI-MOON, CHAIRMAN, GLOBAL COMMISSION ON ADAPTATION: The

--

on CNN NEWSROOM (CNN): The group that came together to help some of the evacuees, I think that there was the Bahamas Methodist Habitat and New Providence Community Center, the two leading guys from that who said, we need to be doing more, and they gathered together a small flotilla of boats that were able to go down from our community here in to Abaco before any of the search and rescue teams, before any of the disaster relief agencies arrived there.

http://transcripts.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/1909/09/cnr.05.html

INDIA HICKS, LIVES IN THE BAHAMAS, WORKING TO GET AIDE TO SURVIVORS (via Skype): Well, here, certainly

--

ENTEN on CUOMO PRIME TIME (CNN): There are only four districts right now, four districts that are currently represented by Democrats, in which Trump won by a larger margin than he won in North Carolina's 9th District.

http://transcripts.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/1909/09/CPT.01.html

First ref: HARRY ENTEN, CNN POLITICS SENIOR WRITER & ANALYST: Yes.

--

FARROW on NEW DAY (CNN): It's $7.5 million that are in that category of either directed or given by Epstein.

http://transcripts.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/1909/09/nday.05.html

First ref: RONAN FARROW, CONTRIBUTING WRITER, "THE NEW YORKER": Sure.

--

CILLIZZA on CNN NEWSROOM (CNN): So, I think he has a very low ceiling and a pretty low floor candidly, but I think he moves in between about 37 percent and 43 percent, 44 percent.

http://transcripts.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/1909/10/cnr.01.html

First ref: CHRIS CILLIZZA, CNN POLITICS REPORTER & EDITOR-AT-LARGE: Good morning, Poppy.

ericaryan commented 5 years ago

Tech & Check Alerts: CNN, Twitter 09/13/19

U.S. on EARLY START (CNN): By the time it was all settled, Justify had become the 13th winner of the prestigious Triple Crown and His owners sold the breeding rights for $60 million.

http://transcripts.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/1909/12/es.02.html