Teichlab / scg_lib_structs

Collections of library structure and sequence of popular single cell genomic methods
417 stars 87 forks source link

Multiome Correction #15

Closed dannyconrad closed 2 years ago

dannyconrad commented 2 years ago

With the release of the v2 scATAC-sq kit, I think we have some additional information to supplement/improve the Multiome schematics. The new ATAC kit uses the same enzyme as the Multiome kit (ATAC Enzyme B, PN 2000265). If the schematics at the end of the v2 protocol are accurate, this means there isn't any modification to the enzyme or its adapter sequences. This suggests that the spacer sequence in the capture oligo enables hybridization of a separate splint oligo, which in turn facilitates the ligation of the gDNA fragment to the capture oligo. The splint oligo is not mentioned anywhere but I think this is the logical conclusion.

I assume that what makes ATAC Enzyme B different is instead just that it is more concentrated, a change they probably had to make to improve sensitivity in the Multiome kit that also enabled them to cut the transposition time in the v2 ATAC kit from 60 -> 30 minutes.

dbrg77 commented 2 years ago

Thanks @dannyconrad for the info.

Indeed, if the enzyme in the scATAC v2 kit and the Multiome kit is the same, the presence of a splint oligo makes more sense. A more concentrated version of Tn5 was used in the Bio-Rad dscATAC/dsciATAC which has been shown to improve the quality metrics, so it is also reasonable to assume the scATAC v2 kit and the Multiome kit use a more concentrated version.

I will update soon.

Thank you.

Xi

dannyconrad commented 2 years ago

Thanks Xi! And thank you as well for helping to build such a wonderful tool. I've used this resource many times and have recommended the schematics to many others to help understand library construction across methods.

dannyconrad commented 2 years ago

Hey @dbrg77, had another thought while working through the schematics.

Ligation requires a 5' phosphate. This means one of two things:

  1. The Nextera R1 adapter loaded into the ATAC Enzyme B has been modified to contain a 5' phosphate
  2. The splint oligo used to bridge the gDNA fragments to the capture oligo has a 5' phosphate

I suppose both could be true but this seems unlikely. Unless I'm mistaken, either method should result in a library that can be permanently barcoded with the gap-fill reaction at 72˚C, but I would assume they would choose to modify the splint oligo rather than modifying the enzyme? Curious to hear your thoughts.

Here is a schematic: image

dannyconrad commented 2 years ago

Ah, SNARE-seq uses a 5' phosphate on the splint, so I assume that's what 10X copied.

dbrg77 commented 2 years ago

Hi @dannyconrad , thanks very much for the post! You already figure out the details for me, lol

The SNARE-seq-like splint/bridging oligo you drew above makes sense and it would be straightforward for them to do that without doing too many modifications. In a regular Tn5 setting for ATAC-seq, the transfer strand is longer (19bp ME + 14 or 15 bp primer entry points), and the non-transfer strand (the one next to the gap) is short, basically 19bp ME.

The reason that I thought they change the Tn5 is the drawing in their Multiome user guide. Check Page 79:

Screenshot 2022-07-02 at 17 18 47

In this drawing, it seems the transfer strand is shorter and the non-transfer strand is longer, which is different from a typical ATAC-seq. Not sure if I should take this drawing seriously ...

For the time being, I will update the page with the splint oligo you draw. In the meantime, I will do some further reading.

Thanks.

Regards, Xi

dbrg77 commented 2 years ago

Oh, never mind. I guess they made a mistake. The picture in the above post is from the RevB of their user guide. In the latest user guid (RevE), page 80, it is the same as the regular ATAC, i.e. the transfer strand is the longer one:

Screenshot 2022-07-02 at 20 58 13
dbrg77 commented 2 years ago

I guess this should be correct. Closing for now. Feel free to re-open, otherwise.