wallet-bifold - Githubissues

Templarian / MaterialDesign

✒7000+ Material Design Icons from the Community

https://materialdesignicons.com

Other

11.03k stars 724 forks source link

wallet-bifold #5963

Closed jhil closed 3 years ago

jhil commented 3 years ago

The wallet / wallet-outline icon most closely represents a wallet clip, while a bifold wallet resonates more with me. I think this variant would be a great addition, as we already have wallet-membership, wallet-giftcard, and wallet-travel. Would love to use this in the app I'm building!

I have:

[x] Searched the current library to make sure the icon doesn't exist.
[x] Searched open issues to make sure there isn't a request for this icon.
[x] Followed the material guidelines.

Preview

Zip Download

wallet-bifold.zip

jhil commented 3 years ago

I actually think this version, with a rounded bottom-left corner, is stronger. Eager to hear feedback!

jhil commented 3 years ago

And here's an example of this style of icon in the wild (Robinhood app)

jhil commented 3 years ago

Here is the SVG of my latest suggestion for wallet-bifold or wallet-bifold-outline. Let me know if anyone has feedback! wallet-outline-bifold.svg.zip

jhil commented 3 years ago

One more alternative idea:

mririgoyen commented 3 years ago

That version has obvious perspective in it, which goes against guidelines.

jhil commented 3 years ago

Oh ok, thanks for letting me know! How did you feel about the prior suggestion? https://github.com/Templarian/MaterialDesign/issues/5963#issuecomment-834758386

If anything, this overlap perspective style is used in other icons in the set, like https://materialdesignicons.com/icon/mailbox-open

mririgoyen commented 3 years ago

We made a very special exception for the mailboxes because they are so commonly used and there wasn't a better way to show them. I don't know if a bi-fold wallet meets that same criteria. 🤔

mririgoyen commented 3 years ago

We're gonna say no to this one because of the perspective issue and the fact that we already have an acceptable option. If there was no other way to show this, we'd probably take it because it was done very well. Sorry!

jhil commented 2 years ago

Would yall be open to reconsidering this? I still find it to be a more compelling and recognizable wallet icon and would love to use it in our app. The current wallet only represents the money clip or "snap" style wallet. If we really wanted to push the perspective principle, this could be interpreted as an open wallet. If you search wallet icons, many of them are the bifold style. Thoughts?

One more alternative idea:

jhil commented 1 year ago

Seeing and hearing no feedback, I'm going to move this one forward!

jhil commented 1 year ago