steodor
commented
1 week ago It's a brand icon, see the third point on your checklist.
Open flopp999 opened 1 week ago
steodor
commented
1 week ago It's a brand icon, see the third point on your checklist.
flopp999
commented
1 week ago Ok, I Interpreter the third point that logos wasn't allowed anymore, but products was allowed. I know that the text says product logos, is this what you mean, that an icon that represent a product also represents a company? A logo for me is a symbol for the company, but after I "talked" to ChatGPT I understand that a product also is a logo. I will delete this PR
steodor
commented
5 days ago It's not that representing a product is the same as representing the company that made it, it's only from a graphical design standpoint that it's the same thing. Any kind of logo would fall into this category no matter what it represents. That's because logos have intrinsic features that more often than not break the Material Design guidelines which this library closely follows. Such as in your example, the 1 pixel line width is a clear violation, and thickening it would misrepresent the product. It's like the linked page says, logos are simply not Material. Sorry.
Now, I wouldn't delete the PR just yet. Please tell me how is this charging robot different from ev-station? If there's a reasonably distinct variation, a new icon can easily make sense, even though it might not resemble the one you provided.
flopp999
commented
5 days ago OK, strange that it got 2 pixels, I one draw with 1 pixel. This is my first icon I make, so I guess I did something wrong. ev-station can be used, it is same function(charge a car), ev-station maybe is more like a charge station that you find on the highways. My icon is for home charging of cars. I am fine to use ev-station since it has same function as mine. I understand that you cannot have an icon for each charger, today there are more than 10 different company that manufacture home chargers :)
steodor
commented
3 days ago I wouldn't know how to depict a "home electric pump" as in the current ev-station icon but with a house instead of that simple shape around the lightning bolt shape, mainly because of the roof that would make everything not fit properly. Hopefully someone with better imagination than me can take a stab at it?
Something like home-lightning-bolt or home-lightning-bolt-outline could also be used perhaps, if the pump/plug element is not mandatory.
Good luck!
flopp999
commented
3 days ago Thanks
I will use ev-station
Daniel
Från: Teodor Sandu @.> Skickat: Wednesday, September 25, 2024 1:35:54 AM Till: Templarian/MaterialDesign @.> Kopia: flopp999 @.>; Author @.> Ämne: Re: [Templarian/MaterialDesign] Easee charging robot (Issue #7525)
I wouldn't know how to depict a "home electric pump" as in the current ev-station icon but with a house instead of that simple shape around the lightning bolt shape, mainly because of the roof that would make everything not fit properly. Hopefully someone with better imagination than me can take a stab at it?
Something like home-lightning-bolthttps://pictogrammers.com/library/mdi/icon/home-lightning-bolt/ or home-lightning-bolt-outlinehttps://pictogrammers.com/library/mdi/icon/home-lightning-bolt-outline/ could also be used perhaps, if the pump/plug element is not mandatory.
Good luck!
— Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHubhttps://github.com/Templarian/MaterialDesign/issues/7525#issuecomment-2372571894, or unsubscribehttps://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AFFQT5IZ3GXJKJS7SSMSH2DZYHZNVAVCNFSM6AAAAABOP6YJSKVHI2DSMVQWIX3LMV43OSLTON2WKQ3PNVWWK3TUHMZDGNZSGU3TCOBZGQ. You are receiving this because you authored the thread.Message ID: @.***>
Before submitting a new icon contribution, please confirm the following:
Tell us about your contribution.
I couldn't find any icon for Easee charging robot https://easee.com/en/products/ev-chargers/
Share a preview of your contribution.
Upload the icon source.
easee.zip