Crops not growing in chunk loaded area(minecraft 1.15.2)

[p3rsik]

mod list:

AI-Improvements-1.15.2-0.3.0.jar angelring-1.15.2-1.2.0.jar AppleSkin-mc1.15.2-forge-1.0.14.jar appliedenergistics2-7.0.0-beta.1.jar astralsorcery-1.15.2-1.12.3.jar BetterMineshaftsForge-1.15.2-1.3.jar Bookshelf-1.15.2-5.6.40.jar Botania-r1.15-388.jar Bountiful+Baubles-1.15.2-0.0.1.jar buildinggadgets-3.3.5.jar ChickenChunks-1.15.2-2.5.0.77-universal.jar Clumps-5.0.2.4.jar CodeChickenLib-1.15.2-3.3.1.379-universal.jar cofh_core-1.15.2-0.4.0b.jar comforts-FORGE-1.15.2-2.0.0.3.jar config-2-3.0.jar CraftingTweaks_1.15.2-11.0.1.jar CraftTweaker-1.15.2-6.0.0.24.jar Cucumber-1.15.2-3.0.9.jar curios-FORGE-1.15.2-2.0.2.6.jar DarkUtilities-1.15.2-3.1.8.jar deathquotes-1.15.1-1.0.jar elevatorid-1.15.2-1.7.1.jar EnchantmentDescriptions-1.15.2-2.0.9.jar EnderStorage-1.15.2-2.5.0.149-universal.jar endertanks-1.15-1.8.1.jar ensorcellation-1.15.2-0.4.1b.jar FastFurnace-1.15.1-3.0.0.jar FastLeafDecay-v22.jar FastWorkbench-1.15.2-3.1.1.jar Hwyla-forge-1.10.8-B72_1.15.2.jar Industrial+Agriculture[Botania]-1.15.2-1.7.0.jar Industrial+Agriculture[Core]-1.15.2-1.7.0.jar Industrial+Agriculture[Industrial+Foregoing]-1.15.2-1.6.1.jar Industrial+Agriculture[Mekanism]-1.15.2-1.6.1.jar industrial-foregoing-1.15.2-2.3.3-e356e61.jar infernalmobs-1.15.2.1.jar InventoryHud_1.15.2.forge-3.0.1.jar inventorysorter-1.15.2-17.0.0.jar invtweaks-1.15.2-2.0.8.jar ironchest-1.15.2-10.0.3.jar jei-1.15.2-6.0.2.12.jar JEIEnchantmentInfo-1.16.1-1.1.0.jar jeiintegration_1.15.2-3.1.0.1.jar JustEnoughResources-1.15.2-0.10.1.77.jar libnonymous-1.15.2-1.1.1.5.jar light-overlay-4.7.0.jar lycanitesmobs-1.15.2-2.2.3.2.jar Mekanism-1.15.2-9.10.9.422.jar MekanismAdditions-1.15.2-9.10.9.422.jar MekanismGenerators-1.15.2-9.10.9.422.jar MekanismTools-1.15.2-9.10.9.422.jar mining_dimension-1.15.2-1.0.4.jar Morpheus-1.15.2-4.2.50.jar MysticalAgriculture-1.15.2-3.0.9.jar NaturesAura-28.4.jar Neat+1.6-22.jar observerlib-1.15.2-1.2.0.v60.jar Patchouli-1.15.2-1.2-35.jar Placebo-1.15.2-3.1.0.jar preview_OptiFine_1.15.2_HD_U_G1_pre30.jar ScalingHealth-1.15.2-3.0.9+54.jar shetiphiancore-1.15-3.7.2.jar SilentLib-1.15.2-4.6.6+59.jar simplybackpacks-1.15.2-1.4.6.jar StorageDrawers-1.15.2-7.0.2.jar swingthroughgrass-1.15.2-1.4.0.jar switchbow-1.6.jar TerraForged-1.15.2-0.1.2.jar themidnight-0.5.9.jar tinyprogressions-1.15.2-4.0.8.jar titanium-1.15.2-2.4.2.jar tombstone-4.5.6.jar valhelsia_structures-15.0.3a.jar WailaHarvestability-mc1.15.2-1.1.12.jar WAWLA-1.15.2-3.0.4.jar Waystones_1.15.2-6.0.2.jar Xaeros_Minimap_20.18.0.1_Forge_1.15.2.jar xptome-1.15.2-v1.1.6.jar

I have a standard tree farm and farm with mystical agriculture crops. I have placed a chunkloader on my base, included farms in chunkloading radius and left for the night. The next evening, when I returned, I found out that all was working fine through the night, except farms. Plants just stopped growing.

[WraithHunter]

Having the same issue. tested with just Chicken Chunks loaded and had the same issue.

[covers1624]

We are going to need more information on how you are reproducing this. Are you in a modded dimension? Are you on a multiplayer server? Have you modified your config file? Feel free to jump on the discord and chat about it: http://discord.gg/9nr3qyC

[WraithHunter]

Can't speak for the OP. On my end reproduction was simply to create a new profile on twitch, minecraft version 1.15.2, forge version 31.2.9, install Chicken Chunks. Create a new flat world, plants seed and water in a chunk, throw down a chunk loader and tp ~10,000 blocks away and wait. regardless of wait time the seeds wouldn't grow. Also tested increasing random tick speed which also had no effect.

[covers1624]

Can you check if something like a command block, or an AE system keeps working in those chunks?

[WraithHunter]

I've tested a command block with a 'say' command connected to a repeater clock. Works as intended.

[covers1624]

Whilst crops aren't growing?

[WraithHunter]

Yup.

[covers1624]

Alright, sounds like the chunks are being forced, but random ticks aren't being fired. Fun..

[WraithHunter]

"Fun" Like a logic error in someone elses code. lol

[WraithHunter]

Just tested on a second system. problem persisted.

[Morpheus1101]

I was able to replicate on 1.15.2 & 1.16.1

[covers1624]

Can someone try with forceload instead of a ChunkLoader?

[Morpheus1101]

1.15.2 Made no Difference

[covers1624]

Appears to be a vanilla mechanic, only chunks loaded by players will have 'chunk ticks' fired. Reference: ServerChunkProvider.tickChunks() ln 356, ChunkManager.isOutsideSpawningRaduis(terrible name, should be isPlayerLoading)

[Kadwen01]

I think this might be more then just Crops. I got a 1.15 world as well and found that my Ranged Pump is not pumping Lava from the Nether to the Overworld (via ender tanks). I got a chunk loader at the base as well as the pump. I have to keep popping into the nether to get the pump to dump into the ender tank. then return to the overworld to feed it into a "storage" tank so my generator has fuel.

[madappe]

I am new to github, was in search of some prlobem solving. I am trying to build my own pack on 1.15.2. and discovered that my chunk loader does not work in the Nether as @Kadwen01 said it above. First I tought its the ender tank or the ranged pump, but its def the chunk loader not loading if i am not in the nether. i def did not change any configs on any mods.

[Morpheus1101]

This has all ready been tested on 31.2.36 and confirmed and tagged by covers as a legit bug hence requiring no more testing on this particular issue currently.

[Letoric]

Just a heads up, the mod "Chonk" has random ticks working in 1.16.x in case looking at that source ( https://github.com/Memebeams/Chonk ) gives you some insight. I know Lat looked at it and made some changes to FTB chunk loader, but random ticks still don't seem to fire with his right now.

[covers1624]

Yeah no, I'm not doing what they do, https://github.com/Memebeams/Chonk/blob/master/src/main/java/com/memebeams/chonk/chunkloading/ChunkManager.java#L96 Ill submit a proper PR to Forge and have things work properly out of the box.

[ghost]

Hi @covers1624, any chance that we can get a new release soon now that this has been fixed? Thanks and appreciate your work on this mod!