TheMinusWorld / forum-improvements

Organize suggestions and other details related to improving the phpBB iteration of the Minus World
BSD 3-Clause "New" or "Revised" License
0 stars 0 forks source link

Imported: Store with post-based currency #39

Open wtl420 opened 8 years ago

wtl420 commented 8 years ago

Fri Aug 24, 2012 04:23 AM Store with post-based currency by Comrade Renzo:

what if there were a store where you could buy things like username changes, or (based on recent suggestions) avatar hats? currency for the store would be based on your posts (for an example, 1 point per post, 5 for a topic, etc)

perhaps you could also dock users points for hidden posts or getting banned, if you'd really want to enforce that

anyways, any thoughts?

Fri Aug 24, 2012 04:28 AM Re: Store with post-based currency by Draku:

Username changes are something that is handed out for free right now with a time restriction. (At least, I believe there's a time restriction.)

I also don't think there should be rewards for post counts -- that supports some pretty bad things like making threads for the sake of making threads.

Fri Aug 24, 2012 04:29 AM Re: Store with post-based currency by Meulin Leijon:

Draku:

I also don't think there should be rewards for post counts -- that supports some pretty bad things like making threads for the sake of making threads.

you mean people don't already do that?

Fri Aug 24, 2012 04:33 AM Re: Store with post-based currency by JoshJDubya:

In order to sell name changes, that would require automation. Making name changes automatic is a terrible idea as there would be no filter to prevent offensive names and the like. Also, it would be considerably harder to manage a name change log, if you cut out the communication with the staff.

As for any store modifications, I personally don't like them because they don't really add anything new or worthwhile. Also, people earning currency for quantity and not quality? @!$% that noise. If anything you should earn currency for positive ratings on a post or likes... which should be added before we do anything like adding a store.

Fri Aug 24, 2012 04:42 AM Re: Store with post-based currency by Comrade Renzo:

well what about something as harmless as hats? this lets people who want hats have hats. points won't really mean much if that's all it gets you

not to mention if you're worry about people spamming for posts, just make double posting against the rules

Fri Aug 24, 2012 04:46 AM Re: Store with post-based currency by JoshJDubya:

Comrade Renzo:

well what about something as harmless as hats? this lets people who want hats have hats. points won't really mean much if that's all it gets you

Well in regards to this discussion, an option to turn them off or turn them off except for special events seems to be a popular vote so this wouldn't work in that regard.

Fri Aug 24, 2012 04:49 AM Re: Store with post-based currency by Comrade Renzo:

i know i mostly posted this as an alternative to turning it on or off completely without entirely derailing the thread

alternate ideas:

-points can be earned through competitions
-make the store carry tbd collectible items

edit: i'm not sure why i said entirely derailing the thread it really wouldn't have ~entirely~

Fri Aug 24, 2012 04:50 AM Re: Store with post-based currency by JoshJDubya:

For the record I wouldn't have considered it derailing as it does involve hat options.

Fri Aug 24, 2012 05:17 AM Re: Store with post-based currency by Elyk:

Kyori suggested MinusPoints back when we just opened the board. I brought up the idea again later when we were discussing making a new forum.

Elyk:

Image
Levels don't mean anything. Each level has a larger gap between the two. Minus points can be rewarded for stuff ranging from winning a competition to even just posting. Numbers in the image are arbitrary.

Achievements/Badges would be listed in reverse chronological order. They would include a date along with the description with old badges just given the date that the system was implemented. There could also be a badge search function, where you could search for the winners of sprite comps, or participants of every secret santa, or people that took place in events before/after a certain date. Mousing over the image wouldn't tell you the name of the award but how many minus points it was worth. Alternatively we could do the reverse where name is mouseover, minus points are listed, or even just list both (Competition Win! 50-p)

This was brought up once again not long ago by Teddy in the development area for the mainsite but with the store idea instead. Point would be used for name changes, cosmetic stuff like hats/name colors/custom member bars. You'd receive points mainly by posting but also for stuff like getting replies to your thread or getting likes on a post you made in addition to the competition wins I mentioned.

I still think it's a cool idea but the amount of work that would be required to go into it is a bit too much right now, especially since Kyori is the only one who can do it and is still busy with his website project.

Fri Aug 24, 2012 05:37 AM Re: Store with post-based currency by Comrade Renzo:

that's a pretty interesting concept honestly

i googled for a second and saw that there are store mods for phpBB but this is just a "hey what do we think of this" suggestion rather than a "I DEMAND HAT STORE" suggestion

Fri Aug 24, 2012 10:30 AM Re: Store with post-based currency by Kyori:

I wouldn't worry about me not being able to work on stuff. I said I'll help out, so if something needs doing it'll get done. It just might take a bit longer than it would if it was the only thing I was focusing on.

Also yeah minus points are good, so is a hat store.

Fri Aug 24, 2012 02:14 PM Re: Store with post-based currency by World'sTallestLadder:

I don't really like stores, I feel like they'd be a waste of time. Pretty big system to set up and I feel like people wouldn't pay it any mind after maybe a month

Fri Aug 24, 2012 02:28 PM Re: Store with post-based currency by Chipper:

Comrade Kesha:

I don't really like stores, I feel like they'd be a waste of time. Pretty big system to set up and I feel like people wouldn't pay it any mind after maybe a month

My experiences have proven this to be true with nearly every extraneous feature of phpBB.

Basically: I do not support this suggestion.

Fri Aug 24, 2012 04:24 PM Re: Store with post-based currency by McKnackus I:

Back when the mainsite was a thing, I thought Minus Points could be interesting because of the more expanded features the site would provide.

However, since that's not happening and we'll be using PHPbb for the forseeable future, I don't think a store or money system would be good at all. Every time I've seen it implemented it's been useless and needlessly complicated, and it usually breaks within the first year of use, especially with PHPbb systems. It'd be a lot of work for something that would essentially be a fad, and I don't feel like it would work well enough to be feasible.

Fri Aug 24, 2012 04:31 PM Re: Store with post-based currency by Comrade Renzo:

fair enough, like i said, this was mostly an alternative to turning hats on/off

though if we keep hats i must insist that we have a hat stop

Fri Aug 24, 2012 06:59 PM Re: Store with post-based currency by Kyori:

we can still use it on the site