search

TheSuperHackers / GeneralsRankedMaps

Generals Zero Hour Ranked Maps
MIT License
8 stars 6 forks source link

[Candidate 1v1 AKAs Magic ZH v1] Map has text imprints that do not fit the style of the map #200

Closed xezon closed 11 months ago

xezon commented 12 months ago

Issue Description The map has text imprints that do not fit the style of the map. The terrain looks natural. The text imprints look unnatural and distracting.

Expected behavior Map looks natural without unexpected terrain text imprints.

Screenshots shot_20230922_153742_30

shot_20230922_153954_36

DoMiNaToRuk2 commented 11 months ago

Will this definitely remain a blocker? This map is sponsored by akabolony. The guy has given $10,000+ in donations to ZH (specifically GR.org) tournaments and challenges. This is his map and a dedication for him.

The white lines for the text are hashed meaning they aren't as visible as if they were solid lines. Regarding whether they "fit the style" of the map is subjective. I personally think it goes well, similar colour to the ruins.

Please re-consider about removing blocker tag and closing this issue as I don't agree with changing it.

xezon commented 11 months ago

Map rules say:

Has no graphics that belong to real or fictional characters, groups, organizations

The "Lucifer Arise" on the "Black Hell" map technically also violates it, but I am going to pass that because "Lucifer" is also a regular name, fits the theme of the map and the way the text is written fits well into the map art.

This is not the case here.

We would also not accept a map with "xezon" written on it.

We can perhaps come to an agreement to pass this one through, if whole community so desires, however, it will not be part of GenTool download because map names and map contents are meant to be neutral.

Also GenTool & Shatabrick are not associated with player.

DoMiNaToRuk2 commented 11 months ago

You say not associated with a player but he is not a player. He is a donator, of $10,000 +

xezon commented 11 months ago

Yes but money can not buy everything. One could make the same argument for someone sponsoring 1 Dollar.

DoMiNaToRuk2 commented 11 months ago

AKAs Magic.zip

Well I disagree, but whatever. Here is new version with AKAs name removed

xezon commented 11 months ago

I can understand the disagreement. Sponsors appreciation is necessary, but Ranked Maps are not the right tool for this. Videos and Forum Posts are.