search

TheThingsIndustries / generic-node-se

Generic Node Sensor Edition
https://www.genericnode.com
Other
110 stars 31 forks source link

GNSE_BSP_Ext_Sensor_I2C2_Init() Failure #240

Open Hexagon3626 opened 2 years ago

Hexagon3626 commented 2 years ago

Environment:

Windows 10 STM32CubeIDE v10.0.0 Generic Node Sensor Edition v1.1

Summary: Basic Project fails when adding _GNSE_BSP_Ext_Sensor_I2C2Init(); within main.c. No problems occur when external i2c is not called or with _GNSE_BSP_Sensor_I2C1Init(); that is already in place

No I2C timings or other parameters have been changed

_HALInit() and _GNSE_BSP_Sensor_I2C1Init(); is called before _GNSE_BSP_Ext_Sensor_I2C2Init();

Steps to Reproduce:

  1. ... Build basic project for GNSE
  2. ... Add GNSE_BSP_Ext_Sensor_I2C2_Init() to main

What do you see now?

Output UART log initialises some peripherals but also states data being received over UART despite no connection:

"01/08/2022 18:36:21", Testing on-board peripherals 

"01/08/2022 18:36:24", Testing on-board peripherals 

"01/08/2022 18:36:24", Testing battery monitoring functionality 

"01/08/2022 18:36:24", DEBUG_USART data received 

"01/08/2022 18:36:24", DEBUG_USART data received 

"01/08/2022 18:36:24", DEBUG_USART data received 

"01/08/2022 18:36:24", DEBUG_USART data received 

"01/08/2022 18:36:24", DEBUG_USART data received 

"01/08/2022 18:36:24", DEBUG_USART data received 

"01/08/2022 18:36:24", DEBUG_USART data received 

"01/08/2022 18:36:24", DEBUG_USART data received

What do you want to see instead?

The standard output below with external i2c working to add functionality

"01/08/2022 18:32:22", Testing on-board peripherals 

"01/08/2022 18:32:22", Testing battery monitoring functionality 

"01/08/2022 18:32:22", MCU internal reference voltage 2832 mv 

"01/08/2022 18:32:22", Battery voltage 3045 mv 

"01/08/2022 18:32:22", Testing LED functionality 

"01/08/2022 18:32:22", Toggling LED lights 

"01/08/2022 18:32:28", Testing secure element functionality 

"01/08/2022 18:32:28", 1) Enabling LOAD_SWITCH_SENSORS 

"01/08/2022 18:32:28", 2) Attempting to read secure element serial number 

"01/08/2022 18:32:28", SE Serial Number:          01 23 88 ce f5 c3 72 5b 27 

"01/08/2022 18:32:28", SE Device EUI:             00 04 a3 10 00 1a b1 8c 

"01/08/2022 18:32:28", SE Application/Join EUI:   70 b3 d5 7e d0 00 00 00 

"01/08/2022 18:32:28", Testing on board sensors functionality 

"01/08/2022 18:32:28", Attempting to read sensors data 

"01/08/2022 18:32:28", Measured Temperature: 28'C & Relative Humidity: 39 

"01/08/2022 18:32:29", Measured Temperature: 28'C & Relative Humidity: 39 

"01/08/2022 18:32:31", Measured Temperature: 28'C & Relative Humidity: 39 

"01/08/2022 18:32:32", Measured Temperature: 28'C & Relative Humidity: 39 

"01/08/2022 18:32:33", Measured Temperature: 28'C & Relative Humidity: 39 

"01/08/2022 18:32:35", Accelerometer acceleration [mg]: X: 24.00     Y: 9.00     Z: -745.00

"01/08/2022 18:32:35", Accelerometer Temperature sensor [degC]:  33.00

"01/08/2022 18:32:36", Accelerometer acceleration [mg]: X: 30.00     Y: 11.00    Z: -874.00

"01/08/2022 18:32:36", Accelerometer Temperature sensor [degC]:  33.25

"01/08/2022 18:32:37", Accelerometer acceleration [mg]: X: 26.00     Y: 8.00     Z: -1010.00

"01/08/2022 18:32:37", Accelerometer Temperature sensor [degC]:  33.25

"01/08/2022 18:32:38", Accelerometer acceleration [mg]: X: 26.00     Y: 10.00    Z: -1006.00

"01/08/2022 18:32:38", Accelerometer Temperature sensor [degC]:  32.75

"01/08/2022 18:32:39", Accelerometer acceleration [mg]: X: 31.00     Y: 7.00     Z: -1002.00

"01/08/2022 18:32:39", Accelerometer Temperature sensor [degC]:  33.50

"01/08/2022 18:32:40", Testing on board external flash functionality 

"01/08/2022 18:32:40", 1) Enabling LOAD_SWITCH_FLASH 

"01/08/2022 18:32:40", 2) Attempting to read & write to external flash 

"01/08/2022 18:32:40",  Start initializing the device and controller
"01/08/2022 18:32:40",  Start matching the device ID
"01/08/2022 18:32:40",       SPI, ID: C22815
"01/08/2022 18:32:40",  ------MxSimpleTest Start!------
"01/08/2022 18:32:40",  ID: C22815
"01/08/2022 18:32:40",  Sr: 00
"01/08/2022 18:32:40",  ERASE START
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",  ERASE DONE
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       **Start Dump data=> address        0
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",                  Length=> 20
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 00000000
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 00000001
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 00000002
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 00000003
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 00000004
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 00000005
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 00000006
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 00000007
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 00000008
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 00000009
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 0000000a
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 0000000b
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 0000000c
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 0000000d
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 0000000e
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 0000000f
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 00000010
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 00000011
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 00000012
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 00000013
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 00000014
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 00000015
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 00000016
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 00000017
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 00000018
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 00000019
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 0000001a
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 0000001b
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 0000001c
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 0000001d
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 0000001e
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 0000001f
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> FF
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",  ERASE PASS
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",  PROGRAM DONE
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       **Start Dump data=> address        0
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",                  Length=> 20
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 00000000
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> 00
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> 00
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 00000001
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> 01
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> 01
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 00000002
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> 02
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> 02
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 00000003
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> 03
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> 03
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 00000004
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> 04
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> 04
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 00000005
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> 05
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> 05
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 00000006
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> 06
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> 06
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 00000007
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> 07
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> 07
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 00000008
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> 08
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> 08
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 00000009
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> 09
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> 09
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 0000000A
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> 0A
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> 0A
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 0000000B
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> 0B
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> 0B
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 0000000C
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> 0C
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> 0C
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 0000000D
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> 0D
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> 0D
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 0000000E
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> 0E
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> 0E
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 0000000F
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> 0F
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> 0F
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 00000010
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> 10
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> 10
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 00000011
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> 11
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> 11
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 00000012
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> 12
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> 12
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 00000013
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> 13
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> 13
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 00000014
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> 14
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> 14
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 00000015
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> 15
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> 15
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 00000016
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> 16
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> 16
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 00000017
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> 17
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> 17
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 00000018
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> 18
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> 18
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 00000019
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> 19
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> 19
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 0000001A
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> 1A
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> 1A
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 0000001B
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> 1B
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> 1B
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 0000001C
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> 1C
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> 1C
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 0000001D
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> 1D
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> 1D
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 0000001E
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> 1E
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> 1E
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",       READ address=> 0000001F
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",               data=> 1F
"01/08/2022 18:32:41",           expected=> 1F
"01/08/2022 18:32:42",  MxSelfTest End!

"01/08/2022 18:32:42", Simple external SPI flash (MX25R1635F) test passed!

"01/08/2022 18:32:42", Finished on-board testing, blinking LEDs forever
azerimaker commented 2 years ago

Thanks, @gsbwallace1996 for reporting this. I'll try to reproduce it and get back to you.