ThioJoe / YT-Spammer-Purge

Allows you easily scan for and delete scam comments using several methods.
GNU General Public License v3.0
4.57k stars 389 forks source link

Filtering: False positves with youtube clip feature #696

Open KwentiN-ui opened 2 years ago

KwentiN-ui commented 2 years ago

Filter Mode

Auto-Smart Mode

Select the Problem

False Positive

(Optional) If 'Other', Enter Very Short Description

No response

Spammer Example / Sample

Bild_2022-02-24_151651

Video / Post Link

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tjQIO1rqTBE&t=183s

(Optional) Additional Info / Context

It appears that the filter also flags legitimate links to YouTube Clips. This feature is not commonly used but I reckon this is an easy fix ^^ Thanks again for this amazing tool!

ThioJoe commented 2 years ago

Can you link to the exact comment directly? Can't seem to find it.

Also can you copy and paste the actual text in the screenshot? I'm messing up some letters apparently when trying to transcribe it.

If the clip goes to the current video, it might be doable to ignore it. But if it goes to some other video there wouldn't be any way to distinguish it from any other kind of link

Firecul commented 2 years ago

https://youtube.com/clip/UgkxTpuOFUle0_lneCcFctO78OiVvBHLdSuw linked clip https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tjQIO1rqTBE&lc=UgxNJ7pdCJ7EAIwJ8Zl4AaABAg Comment chrome_I_Created_a_PERFECT_SNAKE_A I _-_YouTube_-_Google_

KwentiN-ui commented 2 years ago

Thats the one

UgxNJ7pdCJ7EAIwJ8Zl4AaABAg | UCokvQjLQyQ7DbC6Q7YbjWHw | Team | https://youtube.com/clip/UgkxTpuOFUle0_lneCcFctO78OiVvBHLdSuw

It goes to the same video

Saragon4005 commented 2 years ago

If it has /clip/[original video ID] it's likely legit in that case.

ThioJoe commented 2 years ago

Unfortunately the clip's URL doesn't seem to have the original video's ID anywhere in it. There might be a way to do a query on it

UnknownCrafts commented 2 years ago
Screen Shot 2022-03-06 at 10 53 18 AM Screen Shot 2022-03-06 at 10 54 01 AM

I found that the channel id and video id stays the same even if it is a clip so maybe we could check if the clip has the same channel or video id as the original video