ThreeSixtyGiving / standard

The 360Giving data standard for UK philanthropic giving
http://www.threesixtygiving.org
Other
10 stars 15 forks source link

Org ID guidelines - consider giving preference to charity entities #137

Open stevieflow opened 8 years ago

stevieflow commented 8 years ago

The guidance at http://www.threesixtygiving.org/standard/identifiers/#toc-organisation-identifier states that a Companies House number should be used before a charity number (if both are available)

This might need revising, given evidence we have seen in that publishers default to using charity identifiers for grantees.

ekoner commented 8 years ago

Update from @timgdavies:

For interoperability with other data, the company number is ultimately preferable. It also picks out a longer-running status of an organisation (I understand from XXXX that it is possible for company to become a charity, then unregister as a charity, whilst retaining company number - but if a charity converts its underlying legal form it has to change number...)

stevieflow commented 7 years ago

I think we have address this in http://threesixtygiving-standard.readthedocs.io/en/revisions-for-usability/identifiers/ - @timgdavies to check

morchickit commented 7 years ago

@KDuerden - is this reflected now in our guidance?

mariongalley commented 1 year ago

There is publicly available guidance about which Org IDs to use. We don't explicitly say to prefer charity over company number though from what I could see