search

TibiaData / tibiadata-api-go

TibiaData API written in Golang and deployed in container (version v3 and above).
https://api.tibiadata.com
MIT License
84 stars 27 forks source link

Deaths with no killer (assist only) do not appear in the death list #203

Open patters-code opened 1 year ago

patters-code commented 1 year ago

Problem

Not all kills shown on tibia.com appear in the deathlog in tibiadata

Expected behavior

all kills are shown, even if some fields cannot be populated

Detail

Any death without any identifiable killer that only has "assists" is omitted from the death list. These deaths can occur when for example a character is killed only by members of their own guild. Presumably these kills are omitted because not all information is available, (Level the death occurred at etc).

I think these deaths should still appear in the deathlist for the character, otherwise this deathlist does not accurately reflect what happened.

Examples

Characters which (currently) serve as examples:

Extra Background

Deaths of this kind are common on retro-hardcore servers where kill selling is widespread, as being in the same guild as the kill seller reduces protection zone block so buyers do not have to wait the full 15 minutes.

tobiasehlert commented 1 year ago

I'm looking into this and have stored away the required html to make a fix for this.

The interesting thing with for instance Sir Pixxy is that the level is not present in the death entry. Thats why the regex is not catching that entry in the first place.

patters-code commented 1 year ago

yeah - it seems like as it can't be logged as "died at level X by" because it was not classed as a PvE death, and it can't be logged as "killed at level X by" because after they remove "Assist" players from the list of killers, there are none, so it seems it just skips the "cause" part of the log (which is what includes the level) and prints the assists.

You can see this causes similar problems for other fansites too e.g. here: https://www.tibiaring.com/char.php?c=Sir+Pixxy it shows multiple deaths all at the same level because the level is omitted in this situation.

In an ideal world I'd love for Cip to change this behaviour so that the level the character dies at is printed, and it's clarified that it was a PvP death e.g. if the killers list is empty just write something vague "Killed at level X in player combat, Assisted by: Y". I feel like these two data points are "required fields" from the players perspective that should always be conveyed (somehow) in the death log. That's a matter for the proposals forum though!

Pvmendes commented 8 months ago

@tobiasehlert this bug is still available? I will get this problem solved.