TillF / wasa_tests

Test for WASA-SED
The Unlicense
0 stars 1 forks source link

File lake_storage.stat #4

Open alicelg99 opened 3 years ago

alicelg99 commented 3 years ago

This file is present is the folder init_conds in the Input folder but also in the Output folder. For the one in the folder init_conds we have positive values for the volume which are :

Lake volume status (for analysis or model re-start)
Subbasin    reservoir_size_class    volume[m^3]
15  1          0.01
15  2          0.08
15  3          0.74
15  4          2.91
15  5         10.23
69  1          0.01
69  2          0.08
69  3          0.74
69  4          2.91
69  5          0.00

But for each case the file with the same name in the Output folder has zero values for the volume column such as the file as follows :

Lake volume status (for analysis or model re-start)
Subbasin    reservoir_size_class    volume[m^3]
15  1          0.00
15  2          0.00
15  3          0.00
15  4          0.00
15  5          0.00
69  1          0.00
69  2          0.00
69  3          0.00
69  4          0.00
69  5          0.00

Also we note that the file _lake_storage.stat_start in Output folder, organized in the same way, does not have zero values but it has the same values as the file lake_storage.out_ in the init_conds folder.

Note: The files _lake_storage.stat_start and lake_storage.out_ are not present in the Output folder for the cases 5, 6 and 14. And they are empty for the case 15 (and 7 but all the files are empty cf the issue case7).

TillF commented 3 years ago

This is not the case when dosediment=.false. I assume it is about silting up the small reservoirs. Did you find any way to check for the deposition in the small reservoir to see if this is the case?

alicelg99 commented 3 years ago

What is the case corresponding to the small reservoir ?

TillF commented 3 years ago

I suggest you check https://tillf.github.io/WASA-SED/#4-3-output-of-the-reservoir-module and look for the output files for the small reservoirs ("lake_*.out") to see if any of them shows that the storage volume decreases. I just didn't check which file(s) is the best to check this, please try.

TillF commented 3 years ago

I confirm the problem is that the problem is that the small reservoirs completely silt up, thus, cannot retain any more water. This is now visible in lake_maxstorcap.out (needs updateing the executable, it was unavailable before). However, I cannot tell yet if we have a) an excessive unrealistiv erosion rate in our fake cases that just fills up the small reservoirs or b) the rates are ok, but there is a bug in the calculation of sedimentation. You could try to check a), I will look into this after my holiday.