pichfl
commented
4 years ago No need to apologize for a long request, it might just be an indicator, that you're actually requesting multiple things. I'll try to answer as much as I can right away. I also extracted #429 to handle the discussion for the chapter navigation.
A quick solution for your problem from ancient days: Start your file names with a zero prefixed number. Sorting is applied alphanumerically, which means numbers from 001 to 999 will be sorted reliably before any word characters. If metadata is filed correctly, the file name is used for sorting only and will not show up in the UI otherwise.
Feature discussion Given I listen to many longer series myself, I like the idea of having series.
However, using custom metadata as the only way to create this, is not something we can rely on.
While your audiobook collection looks meticulously maintained (consider me impressed), we have many users who just want to dump a folder of MP3 files onto BookPlayer and we have to make sure it works for them as well.
Also, there are ideas to create bound books from single files (see #389), which could provide a way to handle more complex books. We haven't discussed how binding should handle files which include chapter metadata yet, which we should and I just added a comment there as well.
There is also #260 which discusses having a screen for displaying and editing book metadata in a secondary screen to the player, which will be realized with the upcoming card based player redesign (#281 and some other work which is not ready for the public yet)
Both #260 and #389 these need to be handled before starting this issue so everyone gets a chance to use it.
We also need to make sure we do not introduce too many layers of abstraction and organization into the UI so the app stays easy to use.
Our goal by name is to provide a good listening experience, not to manage your audiobook collection. We try to provide very easy ways to import files at any time (and macOS and Airdrop help a lot) so you don't have have all your books on your phone all the time but just carry a few you're currently listening to. (Which corresponds with the fact that many users will continue to have phones that will not fit larger collections anyway)
NCrusher74
steve4jobs4
I don't know how I didn't stumble upon this app last spring when I first started listening to AudioBooks, but I really love it so far.
There are just a couple features that I can't find ANYWHERE, and I've even started learning Swift in order to make my own apps that include them (particularly a library maintenance app for non-DRMed audiobooks for MacOS) but while I'm steadily plugging away at that, I'm not at a level yet where I'd be capable of messing with someone else's working code without needing a lot of guidance and hand-holding. I'd be happy to try to implement these features, but I don't have the skills to do it on my own.
Forgive me for the excess verbiage, but it's hard to make this recommendation without a lot of wordy context.
Basically, as someone who reads/listens to a LOT of series, some of which are series within the chronology of a larger universe (for example, think of Star Wars as a "Universe" containing three, three-book series.)
This can make getting files to fall into the right order difficult without a lot of wordy and/or misleading file-naming and/or metadata tagging. For instance, this is an example of what The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings look like on my drive:
and this is what the metadata looks like in Subler:
Even with some rather long file-names, the Foreword and Prologue of "The Fellowship of the Ring" still get sorted incorrectly. Some of this can be fixed using track numbers, but only if you don't have a book that is in multiple .mp3 or .m4a files (I divided up the parts of the LOTR books to demonstrate this.)
My thought was to use a metadata field that is generally unused (or a custom one) for "Universe", "Series" and their indices. (demonstrated here using TV Show and Episode and Season tags)
For example "The Hobbit" might be (universe) "Middle Earth" Book 1 (assuming you don't have The Simarillion and so forth in your library), but it (technically) wouldn't be part of (series) "The Lord of the Rings".
"The Fellowship of the Ring", however, would be Middle Earth, Book 2, but Lord of the Rings, Book 1. Or maybe "The Lord of the Rings" would be Middle Earth, Book 2, and you'd slot the series in that way, but that only works if you don't have books in a universe that don't interleave between series (see also: David Weber's "Honor Harrington"/"Wages of Sin"/"Saganami Island" series, not to mention the short story anthologies.) If read in chronological order, those fall as follows:
So anyway, my recommendation is for the app to be able to read a certain metadata field for this information, and construct a playlist (which might actually be called a "Series" list to differentiate it from a straight-up playlist) based on how the user wants the books ordered.
And then to display the series title on a separate line from the book title, so that the title field isnt so long:
(also, Chapter Nav buttons should totally be a thing.)
I don't know if Apple CarPlay allows for the metadata fields to be more than the three lines that are there, but something like this would be awesome, too.
Thank you!