TrackerControl / tracker-control-android

TrackerControl Android: monitor and control trackers and ads.
https://trackercontrol.org/
GNU General Public License v3.0
1.93k stars 82 forks source link

Add tasker integration to turn on and off #330

Closed spart0n654 closed 2 years ago

spart0n654 commented 2 years ago

A simple integration with tasker so you can have a profile trigger turning off the VPN for tracker control and turning it back on. Especially useful with android auto because it doesn't with any VPN turned on and it would automate some clicks for me turning it off for me when it connects automatically

kasnder commented 2 years ago

If a third-party app could disable TrackerControl, this would be a security problem. So, I can't implement this. Sorry!

abdulisik commented 2 years ago

To chime in on this, many apps create a bridge specifically for Tasker, not for any third-party app. That shouldn't be a security problem, but rather letting power users add new intents/actions using your app (such as the use case above). An example would be how Sleep as Android does it: https://docs.sleep.urbandroid.org/services/tasker_automate.html

Bazoogle commented 1 year ago

It's been a year, is this something you're willing to reconsider @kasnder? I really don't think it would be a security risk, even AFWall+ has some tasker integrations. You would only give access to tasker, not any app, and you could create a toggle for it off by default so anyone who wants to use it can. I think being able to toggle specific apps with tasker would be useful in countless situations, given the flexibility. It would open the door to a lot of things for a lot of users

kasnder commented 1 year ago

@Bazoogle, thanks for following up. I'm still not convinved by the security implications of such a change.