search

Trevoke / dfworldgen

A website to store/show/rate Dwarf Fortress world generation seeds
2 stars 1 forks source link

Rate parameter sets #2

Closed Trevoke closed 12 years ago

Trevoke commented 12 years ago

How do we rate?

+1 / -1 ? (simple)

1-5 stars? (average the results?) (do we weigh by number of stars instead of averaging?)

Something else?

yamamushi commented 12 years ago

Do we want a scaled model like reddit, or a simple 1-5 scorecard?

Perhaps we have a voting model like reddit for worlds, and then a 1-5 scorecard to rate the quality of worlds individually?

Trevoke commented 12 years ago

I'm not sure I catch what the difference is. Are they two different ways to sort? Are we sorting two different things?

yamamushi commented 12 years ago

Two different things, maybe that's a waste though. I don't know which works better, maybe a single 1-10 scale instead?

Trevoke commented 12 years ago

I'm tempted to start with just a 1-5 star rating, averaged. And if it's not good enough, we do something else.

yamamushi commented 12 years ago

Agreed.