search

Trick-17 / arch-installer

Arch distro installer using archiso
The Unlicense
9 stars 3 forks source link

Server packages #50

Open GPMueller opened 7 years ago

GPMueller commented 7 years ago

At this point we could start working on server packages. The installer is modular enough and we could try around with creating a small home media server.

GPMueller commented 7 years ago

docker should even be enough since services like nextcloud can be run over docker images.

NOhs commented 7 years ago

But do you have the latest versions of the software as docker containers like with native packages on Arch?

GPMueller commented 7 years ago

Probably not quite, but this may be an advantage in this case, as updating the system won't break the containers. Of course one then has to update the containers separately and ensure that migration works. But I suppose this may be easier with docker than doing it rather boilerplate by hand (especially migration).

I find it a bit hard to judge what the better approach is without experience, but I vote we try docker.

NOhs commented 7 years ago

For me this is ok if recent containers are available. But I don't use a rolling release distro to install outdated software. Always having the latest packages is one of the major reason to use Arch for me.

GPMueller commented 7 years ago

I agree. From what I read it seems that one can automate the updating process, so that one could simply update docker images every time one updates the system. Probably they won't be quite as up to date, though...

When using it we will see if it's ok or not.

FYI: if I understand correctly one can manually set up images, which could be given rolling updates, but I'm not sure how much work that would actually be. See this example: https://hub.docker.com/r/aheil/teamspeak3-server/

NOhs commented 7 years ago

I could imagine that manual images are at least as much work as installing the latest arch packages, but we will see.

GPMueller commented 7 years ago

I verified with Markus C. that Docker is definitely the right way to go, using Nginx as reverse proxy for the docker containers one wants to expose. It would be advisable to setup everything using Dockerfiles.

We should also decide which server-specific services should go into autostart (systemctl enable). Created issue #72 for this.