search

TryGhost / Ghost

Independent technology for modern publishing, memberships, subscriptions and newsletters.
https://ghost.org
MIT License
46.86k stars 10.2k forks source link

IME Bug: Ghost suffering IME bug for 2 years and Never Fix it #11460

Closed wuliaopage closed 4 years ago

wuliaopage commented 4 years ago

Complaint

For Bug description, please skip this section.

For Ghost Developer, please don't direct to mobiledoc again, as no one is maintaining that project

Bug summery

Don't be surprised. I'm referring to https://github.com/TryGhost/Ghost/issues/9801

9801 is a serious bug for all IME(input method editor) user. The first character in each paragraph will not be recognized when typing non-latin language such as Chinese, Japanese, Korean in Ghost.

This has been seriously damaged Ghost user experience. For those people in Asian, this bug makes Ghost an unuseable platform, as no one can easily, smoothly type out a single paragraph.

Bug history

This bug has been existing for more than 2 years and neither Ghost nor its editor mobiledoc's maintainer fixed it. Issues related to this bug have been proposed many times, as listed below. https://github.com/bustle/mobiledoc-kit/issues/548 https://github.com/bustle/mobiledoc-kit/issues/589 https://github.com/TryGhost/Ghost/issues/9801

A PR has been proposed one year ago, neither Ghost or mobiledoc merge it!! why??? PR: https://github.com/bustle/mobiledoc-kit/pull/661 https://github.com/soulteary/mobiledoc-kit

Mobiledoc reaction

Ghost direct user to discuss this bug in mobiledoc community and push them to fix this bug.

BUT, I have emailed all maintainers in mobiledoc team to push them merge that PR, also post messages in the community, leave messages in developer's twitter. After one month the only one replied me is an auto-reply email from a passed away developer. I'm sorry for that. But it seems mobiledoc has become a depercated or at least partially deprecated project.

Ghost should not depend on a deprecated editor!! or Please Fix this bug by yourself!!

Some people may not know what exactly this bug is, please look at the following issue.

Issue Summary

non-latin languages input problem in koenig editor

image

As the screen recording above shown, I want to input 你好 using Chinese Pinyin Input method of Mac OS X on the start of line，I type nihao，then got i好n.

The first typed n is inserted after cursor.

To Reproduce

  1. Add a Chinese or Japanese or Korean language in your system
  2. Switch your input language to Chinese or Japanese or Korean
  3. Open Ghost, start a new post
  4. Type some letter like nihao, or anything, you can find this bug

This bug also can be reproduced on https://bustle.github.io/mobiledoc-kit/demo/

GiantappMan commented 4 years ago

jonbb1VvVs

same issue...

Blakeatuk commented 4 years ago

we are still suffering

kevinansfield commented 4 years ago

The first character in each paragraph will not be recognized when typing non-latin language such as Chinese, Japanese, Korean in Ghost.

The proposed PR does not fix this issue, it's entirely separate to the IME input problem and much effort has been put in behind the scenes to resolve it but there is a deeper rework of some of mobiledoc's internals required.

We are aware of the issue but harassment and bullying is not the way to go about getting help. Closing as a violation of our code of conduct https://ghost.org/conduct/.