Closed buraksezer closed 2 months ago
โฑ๏ธ Estimated effort to review: 2 ๐ต๐ตโชโชโช |
๐งช No relevant tests |
๐ No security concerns identified |
โก Key issues to review Error Handling The error handling for JSON marshaling and unmarshaling in the `getStreamsConfig` method might be improved by adding specific actions or fallbacks when an error occurs, rather than just logging and continuing. Redundant Logging Consider reducing redundant logging within the same conditional block for stream configuration changes to improve performance and readability. |
Category | Suggestion | Score |
Possible bug |
Add a continue statement to skip processing when the request is nil___ **Consider handling the case wherer is nil before attempting to replace variables in the stream configuration. This will prevent potential nil pointer dereferences later in the code.** [gateway/mw_streaming.go [244]](https://github.com/TykTechnologies/tyk/pull/6562/files#diff-6f565750150d990575c808f1ca8f38483160dc6edf05f1534cd0bedb27c2e6c8R244-R244) ```diff if r == nil { s.Logger().Debugf("No request available to replace variables in stream config for %s", streamID) -} else { - s.Logger().Debugf("Stream config for %s: %v", streamID, stream) - marshaledStream, err := json.Marshal(stream) - ... + continue } +s.Logger().Debugf("Stream config for %s: %v", streamID, stream) +marshaledStream, err := json.Marshal(stream) +... ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 9Why: The suggestion correctly identifies a potential bug where a nil request could lead to a nil pointer dereference. Adding a continue statement when `r` is nil is a crucial fix to prevent runtime errors. | 9 |
Enhancement |
Include stream ID in error logs for better traceability___ **To improve error handling, consider logging the stream ID along with the errormessage when marshaling or unmarshaling fails. This will help in identifying which stream caused the error more quickly.** [gateway/mw_streaming.go [250-264]](https://github.com/TykTechnologies/tyk/pull/6562/files#diff-6f565750150d990575c808f1ca8f38483160dc6edf05f1534cd0bedb27c2e6c8R250-R264) ```diff if err != nil { - s.Logger().Errorf("Failed to marshal stream config: %v", err) + s.Logger().Errorf("Failed to marshal stream config for %s: %v", streamID, err) continue } ... if err != nil { - s.Logger().Errorf("Failed to unmarshal replaced stream config: %v", err) + s.Logger().Errorf("Failed to unmarshal replaced stream config for %s: %v", streamID, err) continue } ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: Including the stream ID in error logs enhances traceability and debugging, making it easier to identify which stream caused the error. This is a valuable improvement for maintainability and debugging. | 8 |
Maintainability |
Use a boolean variable to store the comparison result for cleaner code___ **Instead of checkingreplacedStream != string(marshaledStream) twice, store the result in a boolean variable to make the code cleaner and potentially improve performance by avoiding repeated conversions and comparisons.** [gateway/mw_streaming.go [255-258]](https://github.com/TykTechnologies/tyk/pull/6562/files#diff-6f565750150d990575c808f1ca8f38483160dc6edf05f1534cd0bedb27c2e6c8R255-R258) ```diff -if replacedStream != string(marshaledStream) { +streamChanged := replacedStream != string(marshaledStream) +if streamChanged { s.Logger().Debugf("Stream config changed for %s: %s", streamID, replacedStream) } else { s.Logger().Debugf("Stream config has not changed for %s: %s", streamID, replacedStream) } ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: The suggestion improves code readability and maintainability by reducing redundancy. While not critical, it is a good practice to simplify the logic and avoid repeated operations. | 7 |
Extract stream processing logic into a separate function for clarity___ **Refactor the nested conditionals for better readability and maintainability byextracting the logic into a separate method or function.** [gateway/mw_streaming.go [241-272]](https://github.com/TykTechnologies/tyk/pull/6562/files#diff-6f565750150d990575c808f1ca8f38483160dc6edf05f1534cd0bedb27c2e6c8R241-R272) ```diff if streamsMap, ok := extension.(map[string]any); ok { + processStreams(streamsMap) +} + +func processStreams(streamsMap map[string]any) { if streams, ok := streamsMap["streams"].(map[string]any); ok { for streamID, stream := range streams { ... } } } ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 6Why: Extracting the nested logic into a separate function can improve code readability and maintainability. However, the impact is moderate as it primarily addresses code organization rather than functionality. | 6 |
User description
This PR fixes bad handling of stream configuration if
*http.Request
passed asnil
ingetStreamsConfig
.I also decided to return an initialized
*StreamsConfig
instead ofnil
to eliminate nil checks in other methods.PR Type
Bug fix, Enhancement
Description
*StreamsConfig
instead ofnil
, which eliminates the need for nil checks in other methods.*http.Request
isnil
by logging the situation and continuing the processing of stream configurations.Changes walkthrough ๐
mw_streaming.go
Improve stream configuration handling and initialization
gateway/mw_streaming.go
*StreamsConfig
instead ofnil
.nil
request by logging and continuing processing.