search

UB-Mannheim / zotkat

Erweiterung von Zotero für die Katalogisierung
GNU Affero General Public License v3.0
45 stars 22 forks source link

WQS: PublicationTitle, issue, volume, pages for Q30000000 #62

Closed zuphilip closed 6 years ago

zuphilip commented 6 years ago

I used Q30000000 for looking up the structure of journal articles in Wikidata. However, recently the structured changed in the example. Issue, volume, pages are now qualifiers of the publication title:

wikidata-structure

@pigsonthewing Should this be changed back in Wikidata? (The changes where made by another WikiCite participant, and look intentially, also I could imagine several possible problems with such a nested approach.)

pigsonthewing commented 6 years ago

There is a dispute over how best to do this. I would argue that the use of sub-properties as shown in your image is optimal because a paper can be published in more than one venue.

Since Zotero cannot write sub-properties (because it does not know the QID of item for the journal), it should continue to write such values as top-level statements. A human (or bot) can alter move them.

zuphilip commented 6 years ago

Do you have a link to this discussion (or is this spread over several discussions)?

pigsonthewing commented 6 years ago

Several discussions; most not very civil.