search

UBC-MDS / abalone_age_classification

In this project, we are classifying abalone snails into "young" and "old" according to their number of rings based on input features such as abalone's gender, height with meat in shell, the weight of the shell, etc.
https://ubc-mds.github.io/abalone_age_classification/
MIT License
0 stars 8 forks source link

Meeting Minutes Dec 7th 10PM-11PM #84

Closed lynnwbl closed 2 years ago

lynnwbl commented 2 years ago

Scribe: Lynn Proof-reader: Kiran

lynnwbl commented 2 years ago

Peer review link: https://github.com/UBC-MDS/data-analysis-review-2021/issues/13

kphaterp commented 2 years ago

Additional Comments from the TA:

  1. Don't include files in your folders that don't mean anything. Everything in your folders will be evaluated.

  2. The readability of your report is not clear on my end. I can't seem to grasp your major findings. Maybe try to sum up all your findings in a summary. It is relatively difficult to absorb what to take away from your findings.

  3. Figure 5. Validation score with different hyperparameter C. Take this figure as an example. You would not see the quality of this image in a scientific report. I don't see how the captions are descriptive or conveying a narrative.

  4. "Your question, analysis and visualization should make sense. It doesn’t have to be complicated, but you should tell a story and have a narrative. Specifically, this should come through in your README and final report file." and "This should be an evolution of what was submitted at the proposal stage. " I might be incorrect but I did not see a visualization in your readme nor did I see a summary narrative of your results. Other groups have been able to bring a sufficient evolution from their previous milestone.

  5. You should have a summary of your findings in a more organized manner. For maximum readability, avoid giving screenshots of tables, avoid computational variables, explain the most important findings in the tables. Summarize your findings in paragraphs that have topic sentences. The narrative should be clear to the reader. In many projects this has been demonstrated, but it's relatively not simple for your report.

kphaterp commented 2 years ago

I will fix figure captions (3) and address points 2 and 5 as well.