Mid-Season Ozone Season (OS) Start (non-GNP/MATS checks from 1.0)

[annalbrecht]

Overview

Some checks not associated with GNP & MATS have been added/updated in 1.0 but have not yet been incorporated into 2.0. These need to be moved over.

CAPD (Charlie Frushour) indicated in the June 13, 2024 ECMPS Support Meeting that we should delay this change indefinitely.

Affected ECMPS 1.0 Tickets

• EC-3923: Updates to Handle New OS Programs that Begin Mid-Season
• EC-3955: Add CSOSG2E to ECMPS.Lookup.PROGRAM_CODE: Already included in ECMPS 2.0.

EC-3923

Background

EC-3923 was implemented in the 2023 Q2 ECMPS 1.0 Release. Its purpose was to allow the C-SAPR NOx OS Group 3 (CSOSG3) Program to begin in the middle of the 2023 ozone season (OS) for Minnesota, Nevada and Utah. These three states were not previously affected by OS programs, and unlike other OS programs or states, CSOSG3 would have began in the middle of the OS for these three states. To allow for this, ECMPS 1.0, which was built on the understanding that OS programs would not start in the middle of OS, was changed to allow mid-season starts.

Based on a July 7th, 2023 email from Chris Worley, Minnesota and Nevada received stay orders for CSOSG3 that results in sources for both states not needing to report for 2023.

Acceptance Tests

Acceptance Test Comment

Proposed Resolution

Because mid-season OS starts are not currently needed, ERG proposes that CAPD suspends or delays the implementation of the EC-3923 changes in ECMPS 2.0.

Because EC-3955 has already been implemented in ECMPS 2.0, suspending or delaying EC-3923 would result in either closing this ticket or moving it 2025 or beyond.

CAPD (Charlie Frushour) indicated in the June 13, 2024 ECMPS Support Meeting that we should delay this change indefinitely.

ECMPS 1.0 Changes Not In ECMPS 2.0

2023 Q2 (EC-3923: CSOSG3)

• Check Changes
  • EMGEN: 1, 5, 7, 8 and 9.
  • HOURAGG: 12, 14, 15 and 16.
  • HOURAPP: 3 and 4.
  • HOURCV: 7 and 16.
  • HOURDHV: 40 and 44.
  • HOURGEN: 1 and 2.
  • HOUROP: 1
  • LME: 42
• Net Changes
  • CheckEngine/CheckData.cs
  • CheckEngine/GeneratedParameterClasses/EmGenerationParameters.cs
  • Emissions/EmissionReport/EmissionsReportProcess.cs
  • Emissions/EmissionReport/Checks/HourlyAggregationChecks.cs
  • Emissions/EmissionReport/Checks/HourlyApportionmentChecks.cs
  • Emissions/EmissionReport/Checks/HourlyCalculatedDataChecks.cs
  • Emissions/EmissionReport/Checks/HourlyDerivedValueChecks.cs
  • Emissions/EmissionReport/Checks/HourlyGeneralChecks.cs
  • Emissions/EmissionReport/Checks/HourlyOperatingDataChecks.cs
  • LME/LMEChecks.cs
  • Emissions/NonOperatingEmissionGeneration/cGenerationChecks.cs
  • Emissions/NonOperatingEmissionGeneration/cGenerationParameters.cs
• Database Data Changes
  • CHECK_CATALOG
  • CHECK_CATALOG_PARAMETER
  • CHECK_PARAMETER_CODE

ECMPS 1.0 Already Included Changes

2023 Q3 (EC-3955: CSOSG2E)

• Database Changes
  • PROGRAM_CODE (CSOSG2E)

[djw4erg]

CHECK_CATALOG Rows

Rows to Delete

Primary Key	Check Code	Check Name
10439	HOURAGG-12	April_NOX_Mass_Calculated_Accumulator_Array	REQ	2131	2832
10460	HOURAGG-14	April_HI_Calculated_Accumulator_Array	REQ	2133	2829
10470	HOURAGG-15	April_Op_Time_Accumulator_Array	REQ	2134	2834
10489	HOURAGG-16	April_Op_Hours_Accumulator_Array	REQ	2135	2835

Rows with Changes

Primary Key	Check Code	Check Name
2336	EMGEN-1	Initialize Emissions Generation for Location
2340	EMGEN-5	Generate NOx Mass YTD and OS Values
2342	EMGEN-7	GenerateTotal Heat Input YTD and OS Values
2343	EMGEN-8	Generate Operating Time YTD and OS Values
2344	EMGEN-9	Generate Operating Hours YTD and OS Values
2131	HOURAGG-12	Compare NOx Mass YTD and OS Values
2133	HOURAGG-14	Compare Total Heat Input YTD and OS Values
2134	HOURAGG-15	Compare Operating Time YTD and OS Values
2135	HOURAGG-16	Compare Operating Hours YTD and OS Values
1732	HOURAPP-3	Calculate Apportioned or Summed Heat Input Rate
2029	HOURAPP-4	Calculate NOx Mass Rate from Apportioned or Summed Heat Input Rate
821	HOURCV-7	Calculate Heat Input
814	HOURCV-16	Calculate NOx Mass Emissions
2140	HOURDHV-40	Determine Fuels Burned for LME Unit
2146	HOURDHV-44	Calculate NOX Mass for LME Unit
1702	HOURGEN-1	Initialize Accumulators, Dictionaries and Lists
1815	HOURGEN-2	Reporting Period Details
535	HOUROP-1	Validate Single Operating Data record for hour
2137	LME-42	Check LTFF Total Heat Input

[djw4erg]

CHECK_CATALOG_PARAMETER Rows with Changes

Primary Key	Check Code	Parameter Name	Usage	Check Catalog Key	Check Param Key
16652	EMGEN-1	Location_Program_Records	REQ	2336	301
16653	EMGEN-1	OS_Active_Program_Earliest_UMCBD	OUT	2336	4747
16654	EMGEN-5	OS_Active_Program_Earliest_UMCBD	REQ	2340	4747
16655	EMGEN-7	OS_Active_Program_Earliest_UMCBD	REQ	2342	4747
16656	EMGEN-8	OS_Active_Program_Earliest_UMCBD	REQ	2343	4747
16657	EMGEN-9	OS_Active_Program_Earliest_UMCBD	REQ	2344	4747
16642	HOURAGG-12	OS_Active_Program_Earliest_UMCBD	REQ	2131	4747
16623	HOURAGG-12	OS_NOXM_Calculated_Accumulator_Array	REQ	2131	4743
16647	HOURAGG-12	OS_NOXM_Calculated_Quarterly_Value	OUT	2131	4748
16637	HOURAGG-12	OS_Reporting_Period_Begin_Date	REQ	2131	4746
16643	HOURAGG-14	OS_Active_Program_Earliest_UMCBD	REQ	2133	4747
16617	HOURAGG-14	OS_HIT_Calculated_Accumulator_Array	REQ	2133	4742
16648	HOURAGG-14	OS_HIT_Calculated_Quarterly_Value	OUT	2133	4749
16638	HOURAGG-14	OS_Reporting_Period_Begin_Date	REQ	2133	4746
16644	HOURAGG-15	OS_Active_Program_Earliest_UMCBD	REQ	2134	4747
16631	HOURAGG-15	OS_Op_Time_Calculated_Accumulator_Array	REQ	2134	4745
16649	HOURAGG-15	OS_OPTIME_Calculated_Quarterly_Value	OUT	2134	4750
16639	HOURAGG-15	OS_Reporting_Period_Begin_Date	REQ	2134	4746
16645	HOURAGG-16	OS_Active_Program_Earliest_UMCBD	REQ	2135	4747
16630	HOURAGG-16	OS_Op_Hours_Calculated_Accumulator_Array	REQ	2135	4744
16650	HOURAGG-16	OS_OPHOURS_Calculated_Quarterly_Value	OUT	2135	4751
16640	HOURAGG-16	OS_Reporting_Period_Begin_Date	REQ	2135	4746
16616	HOURAPP-3	OS_HIT_Calculated_Accumulator_Array	REQ	1732	4742
16618	HOURAPP-3	OS_Reporting_Period_Begin_Date	REQ	1732	4746
16624	HOURAPP-4	OS_NOXM_Calculated_Accumulator_Array	REQ	2029	4743
16625	HOURAPP-4	OS_Reporting_Period_Begin_Date	REQ	2029	4746
16619	HOURCV-7	OS_HIT_Calculated_Accumulator_Array	REQ	821	4742
16620	HOURCV-7	OS_Reporting_Period_Begin_Date	REQ	821	4746
16626	HOURCV-16	OS_NOXM_Calculated_Accumulator_Array	REQ	814	4743
16627	HOURCV-16	OS_Reporting_Period_Begin_Date	REQ	814	4746
16621	HOURDHV-40	OS_HIT_Calculated_Accumulator_Array	REQ	2140	4742
16622	HOURDHV-40	OS_Reporting_Period_Begin_Date	REQ	2140	4746
16628	HOURDHV-44	OS_NOXM_Calculated_Accumulator_Array	REQ	2146	4743
16629	HOURDHV-44	OS_Reporting_Period_Begin_Date	REQ	2146	4746
16611	HOURGEN-1	OS_HIT_Calculated_Accumulator_Array	OUT	1702	4742
16612	HOURGEN-1	OS_NOXM_Calculated_Accumulator_Array	OUT	1702	4743
16613	HOURGEN-1	OS_Op_Hours_Calculated_Accumulator_Array	OUT	1702	4744
16614	HOURGEN-1	OS_Op_Time_Calculated_Accumulator_Array	OUT	1702	4745
16636	HOURGEN-2	Current_Reporting_Period_Begin_Date	REQ	1815	4630
16635	HOURGEN-2	Current_Reporting_Period_End_Date	REQ	1815	4631
16641	HOURGEN-2	OS_Active_Program_Earliest_UMCBD	OUT	1815	4747
16615	HOURGEN-2	OS_Reporting_Period_Begin_Date	OUT	1815	4746
16632	HOUROP-1	OS_Op_Hours_Calculated_Accumulator_Array	REQ	535	4744
16633	HOUROP-1	OS_Op_Time_Calculated_Accumulator_Array	REQ	535	4745
16634	HOUROP-1	OS_Reporting_Period_Begin_Date	REQ	535	4746
16659	LME-42	OS_HIT_Calculated_Accumulator_Array	REQ	2137	4742

[djw4erg]

CHECK_PARAMETER_CODE Rows with Changes

Note that the Source Table column is null for these rows.

Primary Key	Name / Description / Display Name	Data Type	Param Type	Object Type
4742	OS_HIT_Calculated_Accumulator_Array / Array containing ozone season HIT accumulated value for each location. / OS HIT Calculated Accumulator Array	OBJECT	AGGARRY	decimal?[]
4749	OS_HIT_Calculated_Quarterly_Value / The recalculated ozone-season quarterly value for total heat input. / OS HIT Calculated Quarterly Value	DECIMAL	OUTPUT
4743	OS_NOXM_Calculated_Accumulator_Array / Array containing ozone season NOXM accumulated value for each location. / OS NOXM Calculated Accumulator Array	OBJECT	AGGARRY	decimal?[]
4748	OS_NOXM_Calculated_Quarterly_Value / The recalculated ozone-season quarterly value for NOx Mass. / OS NOXM Calculated Quarterly Value	DECIMAL	OUTPUT
4744	OS_Op_Hours_Calculated_Accumulator_Array / Array containing ozone season Op Hours accumulated value for each location. / OS Op Hours Calculated Accumulator Array	OBJECT	AGGARRY	int?[]
4745	OS_Op_Time_Calculated_Accumulator_Array / Array containing ozone season Op Time accumulated value for each location. / OS Op Time Calculated Accumulator Array	OBJECT	AGGARRY	decimal?[]
4751	OS_OPHOURS_Calculated_Quarterly_Value / The recalculated ozone-season quarterly value for total operating hours. / OS OPHOURS Calculated Quarterly Value	INTEGER	OUTPUT
4750	OS_OPTIME_Calculated_Quarterly_Value / The recalculated ozone-season quarterly value for total operating time. / OS OPTIME Calculated Quarterly Value	DECIMAL	OUTPUT
4746	OS_Reporting_Period_Begin_Date / When OS Reporting Required is true, the date to use as the beginning of OS reporting in the emission report. Usually the first date of the quarter, but if the earliest UMCBD for an associated OS program is in the quarter, then it is that date. / OS Reporting Period Begin Date	DATE	OUTPUT

[djw4erg]

Acceptance Tests

Copied from EC-3923

• [ ] HOURAGG-12
  • [ ] Confirm some example results fire/don’t fire as expected
  • [ ] Result C
    • [ ] Fires as expected
    • [ ] Doesn’t fire as expected
  • [ ] Result G
    • [ ] Fires as expected
    • [ ] Doesn’t fire as expected
  • [ ] Result H
    • [ ] Fires as expected
    • [ ] Doesn’t fire as expected
  • [ ] Result I
    • [ ] Fires as expected
    • [ ] Doesn’t fire as expected
• [ ] HOURAGG-14
  • [ ] Confirm some example results fire/don’t fire as expected
  • [ ] Result C
    • [ ] Fires as expected
    • [ ] Doesn’t fire as expected
  • [ ] Result G
    • [ ] Fires as expected
    • [ ] Doesn’t fire as expected
  • [ ] Result H
    • [ ] Fires as expected
    • [ ] Doesn’t fire as expected
  • [ ] Result I
    • [ ] Fires as expected
    • [ ] Doesn’t fire as expected
• [ ] HOURAGG-15
  • [ ] Confirm some example results fire/don’t fire as expected
  • [ ] Result C
    • [ ] Fires as expected
    • [ ] Doesn’t fire as expected
  • [ ] Result F
    • [ ] Fires as expected
    • [ ] Doesn’t fire as expected
  • [ ] Result G
    • [ ] Fires as expected
    • [ ] Doesn’t fire as expected
  • [ ] Result H
    • [ ] Fires as expected
    • [ ] Doesn’t fire as expected
• [ ] HOURAGG-16
  • [ ] Confirm some example results fire/don’t fire as expected
  • [ ] Result C
    • [ ] Fires as expected
    • [ ] Doesn’t fire as expected
  • [ ] Result F
    • [ ] Fires as expected
    • [ ] Doesn’t fire as expected
  • [ ] Result G
    • [ ] Fires as expected
    • [ ] Doesn’t fire as expected
  • [ ] Result H
    • [ ] Fires as expected
    • [ ] Doesn’t fire as expected
• [ ] HOURAPP-3
  • [ ] Run example file through OS HIT Calculated Accumulator Array for this location = OS HIT Calculated Accumulator Array for this location + ( HI Calculated Apportioned Value * Apportionment OpTime Array for this Location ) path 1 and confirm no issues
  • [ ] Run example file through OS HIT Calculated Accumulator Array for this location = OS HIT Calculated Accumulator Array for this location + ( HI Calculated Apportioned Value * Apportionment OpTime Array for this Location ) path 2 and confirm no issues
  • [ ] Run example file through OS HIT Calculated Accumulator Array for this location = OS HIT Calculated Accumulator Array for this location + ( HI Calculated Apportioned Value * Apportionment OpTime Array for this Location ) path 3 and confirm no issues
  • [ ] Run example file through OS HIT Calculated Accumulator Array for this location = OS HIT Calculated Accumulator Array for this location + ( HI Calculated Apportioned Value * Apportionment OpTime Array for this Location ) path 4 and confirm no issues
  • [ ] Run example file through OS HIT Calculated Accumulator Array for this location = OS HIT Calculated Accumulator Array for this location + ( HI Calculated Apportioned Value * Apportionment OpTime Array for this Location ) path 5 and confirm no issues
• [ ] Submission and synchronization of Q3 OS totals for HITOS, NOXMOS, OSHOURS and OSTIME (needed to properly calculate Q4 OS totals for affected MN, NV and UT units in this 1st year of CSOSG3 program)
  • [ ] Example MN, NV or UT unit
  • [ ] Existing OS affected unit not affected by CSOSG3 updates
• [ ] Non- [ ]operating files for MN, NV, and UT units
• [ ] General LME testing and LME Utility (see comment for further details)
• [ ] Run examples with CSOSG3 beginning mid ozone season in Q2 instead of Q3
• [ ] Test CSOSG2 to CSOSG3 example where G2 ends 8/3 and G3 begins 8/4 (this is scheduled to occur for other states affected by GNP)
• [ ] Super Evals

[djw4erg]

Closing Ticket

CAPD (Charlie Frushour) indicated in the June 13, 2024 ECMPS Support Meeting that we should delay this change indefinitely.