search

USEPA / EPANET2.2

Perform extended-period simulation of the hydraulic and water quality behavior within drinking water distribution systems
141 stars 54 forks source link

Results differ between GUI and command line version #34

Closed snaeimi closed 3 years ago

snaeimi commented 4 years ago

Hi. I have a network file for which I'm performing a hydraulic analysis. Some result differ between EPANET GUI version and epanet command line file provided with the package. The results between command line and DLL that I exported from source code, downloaded from the ebsite is consistent. So, it's not clear if the results from EPANET GUI is the correct one or the result from command line version. I'm using Pressure-Demand Analysis

rjanke20 commented 4 years ago

Can you please describe exactly what you performed and provide more details on the differences, including, if possible, the network model (janke.robert@epa.gov)? It is not clear what you mean by "exported from the source code".

snaeimi commented 3 years ago

I couldn't check the file. The discrepancy between results arose from the changes of inp file of former version of EPANET. The GUI automatically would amend the older file of version; however, the command line of EPANET(.exe file) does not. It has been a while and I don't remember feature that caused the problem. The fact that matters is that it is not a problem/bug with EPANET