search

USGCRP / gcis-ontology

Ontology for the Global Change Information System
4 stars 7 forks source link

Additional relationship between finding and figure #67

Closed CurtTilmes closed 9 years ago

CurtTilmes commented 9 years ago

I see a strong relationship from Chapter -> Figure and Chapter -> Finding, but do you have a relationship from Finding -> Figure?

something like http://data.globalchange.gov/report/nca3/chapter/our-changing-climate/finding/us-temperature-increased gcis:isDepictedIn (or illustrated by, Supported by, etc.) http://data.globalchange.gov/report/nca3/chapter/our-changing-climate/figure/observed-us-temperature-change

Everything seems based around the Chapter, but I think of those really as just containers --- the important bits of the report are really the findings.

With that relationship, you could even pop figure thumbnails (the right ones) up into the finding html (and on the finding thumbs page: http://data.globalchange.gov/report/nca3/finding?thumbs=1)

You could also infer a bit more about the dataset support for findings. If a dataset was used to make a map or graph supporting a figure that illustrates a finding, then you know that the dataset can be used to understand that finding.

bduggan commented 9 years ago

I would like to see these relationships in GCIS, too.

I can add selections to the interface so that someone can enter them.

What is a good list of relationships to present? Do we need a new element in the GCIS ontology? Do any other ontologies have something like "gcis:isDepectedIn/SupportedBy" already?

Brian

justgo129 commented 9 years ago

We have gcis:isSupportedBy but it doesn't explicitly pertain to figures or datasets: gcis:isSupportedBy a owl:ObjectProperty ; rdfs:label "Is Supported By" ; rdfs:comment "A finding is supported by data, models, model runs, software, etc."; rdfs:domain gcis:Finding .

xgmachina commented 9 years ago

I will update the rdfs:comment of gcis:isSupportedBy to reflect the discussion.

xgmachina commented 9 years ago

Changed the rdfs:comment to "A finding is supported by or depicted in data, figures, models, model runs, software, etc.";

justgo129 commented 9 years ago

Thanks, @xgmachina but given previous discussions, I thought we were getting away from using "model run."

justgo129 commented 9 years ago

Hi @xgmachina, it would be help me a lot if we could wait to close issues until after the merging of the corresponding pull request. Thanks so very much.

xgmachina commented 9 years ago

Yes, let's leave this open because a few more edits will be made.

justgo129 commented 9 years ago

@xgmachina, given that #150 has been merged, are we all right to close this ticket?

justgo129 commented 9 years ago

Closed #67, feel to reopen if desired.