Rename the CSSR Figure Identifiers

[lomky]

CSSR Figures were named by the first filename of an image associated with them. This leaves some problems in the naming including wrong numbers referenced, outdated info, etc, being encoded into the identifier. Let's go through and update the identifiers to be more appropriate.

Must be done in coordination with TSU, or else the Metadata Tool & CSSR website will break.

[lomky]

Tracker sheet

[angel-li]

When you would like to start this process?

On Dec 6, 2017, 12:42 PM -0500, Kathryn Tipton notifications@github.com, wrote:

Tracker sheet — You are receiving this because you were assigned. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub, or mute the thread.

[lomky]

We can start as soon as tomorrow. I think the first step is just coming up with the new IDs in the spreadsheet, which Amrutha is going to take the lead on, that you guys just have to sign off on. See the process tab in the spreadsheet

[amruelama]

@angel-li @kjrhody I have created new IDs (Column H) for the figures. If it's okay with TSU, I'll update the new IDs on GCIS stage. Please note that there are a couple title changes(typos) as well.

[kjrhody]

@amruelama We need to run this by others at TSU and also will need to ensure that the new IDs do not exist anywhere else in the GDAS database (since many figures tend to get reused). If they do, it might cause as-yet-unknown issues. For changes(typos) are you talking about changing the actual title of the figure, or just modifying the proposed ID to reflect a typo fix? I should also say it is fine to go ahead and update GCIS but it will break until we can update them in GDAS, and we need to double check that they don't already exist anywhere else first.

[amruelama]

@kjrhody Sounds good! Let me know if there are figures that are already available in GDAS database with the new identifiers I created. I checked this with GCIS figures to make sure I am not creating any duplicates. But I am not very sure if a figure of a different report (say NCA3) with the same identifier is identified as duplicates in GCIS. @lomky Could you help me with this?

The typo fixes are trivial errors. I checked with the actual chapter PDFs to make sure we are updating it right. When I noticed these typos I thought we might as well update the titles to reflect these updates including the identifiers. Let me know if this makes sense.

[kjrhody]

@amruelama Ok cool - yeah I am most concerned about NCA4 (which is not in GCIS) since I think there are some cloned figures there. So we can check and get back to you guys.

The reason we'd need to know about the typos being in the actual titles is if we need to change the titles in GDAS it will change the metadata which Sarah will need to know about. So we'll need to know which ones were changed or updated.

[amruelama]

Thanks @kjrhody. I haven't updated any titles with typos (in GCIS) yet. Please see the notes column in the above working sheet where I have mentioned the changes required. Let me know what you think.

@lomky Also, I searched for 'indicators-of-warming' in GCIS and returned 3 results. These three have the same title, but different identifiers. For example, for NCA3 figures, one of these have been updated with prefix 'caq' to avoid duplicates whereas the other one doesn't have a prefix in identifier. However, this wouldn't affect CSSR's Indicators of Warming from Multiple Datasets figure because the word 'dataset' was split into 'data-set' for NCA3 figures. I think, in future we should coordinate to figure out a consistent way to create these identifiers.

[lomky]

@amruelama I ran all the identifiers in a query and only found two conflicts. They're marked in red on the sheet.

If we are super concerned with duplication of identifiers, could we just append -cssr to the end of the identifiers? @kjrhody @amruelama

I think fixing the Titles on GCIS should not have any affect on GDAS or the report.

The query:

SELECT identifier from figure where identifier IN ('indicators-of-warming-from-multiple-datasets',
'global-land-and-ocean-temperature-anomalies',
'surface-temperature-change',
'projected-global-temperatures',
'hiatus-box',
'global-mean-temperature-change',
'annually-averaged-precipitation-trends',
'1700-years-of-global-temperature-change-from-proxy-data',
'proxy-temperature-reconstructions',
'climate-interactions-with-land-use',
'anthropogenic-radiative-forcing-contributions',
'observed-and-projected-changes-in-frost-free-season',
'changes-in-length-of-growing-season',
'change-in-annual-sea-ice-extent',
'trends-in-sea-ice-melt-season',
'glacier-mass-loss',
'changes-in-muir-glacier-extent',
'permafrost-temperature',
'relative-sea-level',
'sea-level-rise-co2-and-historical-global-mean-sea-level',
'changes-in-sea-level-in-sea-surface-height',
'projected-global-mean-and-relative-sea-level',
'tidal-floods',
'ocean-heat-uptake',
'ocean-heat-content',
'projected-changes-in-sst',
'ocean-carbonate-chemistry',
'surface-ph-in-2090s',
'dissolved-oxygen',
'cumulative-total-anthropogenic-co2-emissions-from-1870',
'global-co2-emissions-and-probabilistic-temperature-outcomes-of-paris',
'global-emission-pathways-for-greenhouse-gases',
'compound-extremes-and-tippling-elements',
'earths-energy-budget',
'simplified-conceptual-framework-of-the-climate-system',
'radiative-forcing-of-climate',
'atmospheric-concentrations-of-co2-ch4-and-n2o',
'radiative-forcing-of-well-mixed-gases',
'time-evolution-of-forcings',
'co2-sources-and-sinks',
'global-mean-temperature-change',
'attributable-warming-or-cooling-influences-of-anthropogenic-and-natural-forcings',
'estimates-of-forcings-contributions-to-temperature-change',
'emissions-concentrations-and-temperature-projections',
'global-mean-temperature-anomalies-rcps',
'a-climate-modeling-timeline',
'model-spatial-comparison',
'uncertainty-in-decadal-mean-temperature',
'atmospheric-circulation',
'el-nino-and-la-nina-winters',
'cold-season-relationship-between-climate-indices-and-precipitation-temperature-anomalies',
'winter-surface-air-temperature-and-precipitation',
'observed-changes-in-annual-winter-and-summer-temperature',
'pollen-based-temperature-reconstruction',
'observed-changes-in-the-coldest-and-warmest-temperatures',
'observed-changes-in-cold-and-heat-waves',
'observed-changes-in-the-occurrence-of-record-setting-daily-temperatures',
'assessment-of-annual-surface-temperature-trends',
'projected-changes-in-annual-average-temperatures',
'projected-change-in-coldest-and-warmest-daily-temperatures',
'projected-changes-in-maximum-and-minimum-temperatures',
'annual-and-seasonal-changes-in-precipitation',
'observed-change-in-daily-20-year-return-level-precipitation',
'2-day-precipitation-events-exceeding-5-year-recurrence-interval',
'observed-change-in-heavy-precipitation',
'projected-change-in-seasonal-precipitation',
'future-projection-of-regional-extreme-precipitation-of-2-day-duration-and-5-year-return',
'projected-change-in-daily-20-year-extreme-precipitation',
'change-in-the-number-of-days-within-precipitation-percentile-intervals',
'projected-change-in-soil-moisture-end-of-century-higher-emissions',
'projected-change-in-snow-water-equivalent',
'trends-in-the-annual-number-of-large-fires-in-the-western-united-states',
'tropical-cyclone-peak-lifetime-intensity',
'tracks-of-simulated-category-4-5-tropical-cyclones',
'annual-tornado-activity-in-the-us-1955-2013',
'atmospheric-rivers',
'tropospheric-temperature',
'co2-sources-and-sinks',
'model-skill-independence-weights',
'precipitation-projections',
'global-temperatures-continue-to-rise',
'nca-regions',
'multiyear-sea-ice-has-declined-dramatically',
'confidence-likelihood',
'human-activities-are-the-primary-driver-of-recent-global-temperature-rise',
'greater-emissions-lead-to-significantly-more-warming',
'significantly-more-warming-occurs-under-higher-greenhouse-gas-concentration-scenarios',
'record-warm-daily-temperatures-are-occurring-more-often',
'extreme-precipitation-has-increased-across-much-of-the-united-states',
'large-scale-patterns-of-natural-variability-affect-us-climate',
'recent-sea-level-rise-fastest-for-over-2000-years',
'nuisance-flooding-increases-across-the-united-states');

[amruelama]

@lomky Thanks! The identifier 'co2-sources-and-sinks' got mixed-up somehow, I just fixed it. So we have only one duplicate identifier - I'll look at it now.

[lomky]

In #631 one of the improvements is adding a gcis-identifier field. Once that field is added and programmed in, we can come back to these, update the names in both places, and finalize this ticket.