search

USGCRP / gcis

Global Change Information System
https://data.globalchange.gov
Other
20 stars 16 forks source link

CSSR Likelihood & Confidence tables #570

Closed lomky closed 5 years ago

lomky commented 6 years ago

The CSSR has a likelihood table and a confidence table that displays with each finding to contextualize the statements. GCIS needs to encapsulate this data in some ways.

Options:

  1. Create two Tables and associate them with every CSSR finding
    1. Somewhat problematic, as they are not actually tables in the report, as we have used the Tables in the past.
  2. Add the information to the finding information. somewhere.
  3. Create two Arrays and associate them with every CSSR finding (bypasses the Tables problem from 1)
  4. Use the two Figures containing this information from the Executive Summary & associate those with the findings
  5. Something else.
rasherman commented 6 years ago

I believe the likelihood tables are with the Key Findings, not with the Figures. Basically same issue, but changes what they would be linked to.

lomky commented 6 years ago

corrected. Thanks @rasherman!

amruelama commented 6 years ago

Here are the two arrays I've created. Let me know what you think. @rasherman @lomky

  1. Confidence Level
  2. Likelihood

I didn't want to create table inside the report as this is just for reference and provenance purpose. Note that I have used the relationship prov:wasInformedBy and will be using the same term while I relate these arrays to 'key findings'. Any objection or suggestion?

lomky commented 6 years ago

@amruelama did we decide to go with method 3 then? I was actually leaning towards using the existing Executive Summaries figures and related it via provenance.

lomky commented 6 years ago

Would everyone be okay with discussing this at a tagup and seeing if we can make a decision?

lomky commented 6 years ago

We're going to go with path 4, and use prov:wasDerivedFrom to connect the Findings to the Figures.

amruelama commented 6 years ago

@lomky Correction to path 4 - The figure 'Confidence/Likelihood' appears in the Front Matter of CSSR

amruelama commented 6 years ago

It looks like the finding page doesn't display the provenance relationship, but I can see the relationship displayed on figure page - https://data-stage.globalchange.gov/report/climate-science-special-report/chapter/front-matter/figure/confidence---likelihood. Should we change the display for findings in this case?

lomky commented 6 years ago

Yup. Please add a ticket for it!

amruelama commented 5 years ago

Linked CSSR findings to 'Front matter' figure.